Towards an Ethic of Reciprocity: The Messy Business of Co-creating Research with Voices from the Archive

Main Article Content

Rebecca Jane McLaughlan
http://orcid.org/0000-0001-6909-009X

Abstract

Do contemporary practices of attribution go far enough in acknowledging the contribution that others make to our work, particularly when they speak from the archive? The autobiographical fiction Faces in the Water (1961) from acclaimed author Janet Frame (1924-2004) draws on her experiences of residing in various New Zealand mental hospitals between 1945 and 1953. It is a rare and comprehensive account of the patient experience of these institutions that provided a critical lens for my doctoral research. Perhaps more importantly, through this text Frame taught me how difficult histories should be written, about the ambiguities we must accept and the value adjustments to be made in order to make sense of confounding inhumanity. Nowhere within my dissertation is the depth of this contribution acknowledged; a position developed out of respect for her family’s active opposition to the ‘patronising’ and ‘pathologising discourse’ that continues to haunt contemporary receptions of Frame’s work. Within this paper I employ autoethnography to make explicit the process of working through a question that haunted me well beyond the completion of my doctoral research: whether contemporary practices of citation and acknowledgement are sufficient to value research contributions from beyond the grave. I will examine whether Frame’s contribution is commensurate with contemporary qualifications for co-authorship and the burdens of academic practice that act to suppress these conversations.

Article Details

Section
Articles (Peer Reviewed)
Author Biography

Rebecca Jane McLaughlan, University of Melbourne

Rebecca McLaughlan is a lecturer in architectural design at the Melbourne School of Design, University of Melbourne. Her research takes place at the intersection of architecture, medicine, media and pedagogy; specifically the potential of the built environment to support wellbeing with palliative care settings as a current obsession. She is a lover of fine fiction and remains thankful that her naïve choice of doctoral research topic introduced her to Janet Frame and, by extension, one of her favourite novels: Towards Another Summer.