The Presence of Palestinian Absence in Narrating the Zionist Nation into Being

Main Article Content

Annie Pfingst


In 2005, the 38th year of the Israeli military occupation of the Palestinian West Bank, Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem and the year that saw the construction of an eight metre high concrete Wall of Separation through the Occupied West Bank, an exhibition, 'The New Hebrews: A Century of Israeli Art', was held at Martin-Gropius-Bau, Berlin.


The exhibition can be read as the narration of the Zionist nation coming into being – a narration in which the Palestinian people do not figure, though the reconfiguration of the land does. Only in the room on Conflict are Palestinian refugees, the Occupation and the Wall represented by Israeli photographers and media artists, making a slight dent into a historiography and landscape devoid of Palestinian agency and presence.


From a Jewish feminist engagement with the discourses on Palestinian Right of Return, the essay addresses a set of questions about the field of vision posed by Ariella Azoulay in Death’s Showcase: The Power of Image in Contemporary Democracy (2001) when she asks: Who sees? Who is capable of seeing, what, and from where? Who is authorised to look? How is this authorization given or acquired? In whose name does one look?


What can be seen outside the narrative of redemption and the frame set by the Temple Scroll and the Jug of Tears? Are the photographs of the Intifada and the portraits from the refugee camps in effect inserting the presence of the spectral other, as described by Judith Butler? This essay will consider the ways in which we might read these Israeli photographic insertions in the circumstance where representation and representational space is such a contested feature of the conflict.

Article Details

Articles (Peer Reviewed)
Author Biography

Annie Pfingst, University of Technology Sydney

Annie Pfingst is writing on the discourses that frame the Palestinian right of return for doctoral research at the University of Technology, Sydney. Her work as an artist and her research are concerned with embodied knowledges of absence - presence and the layered narratives of place; with memory and the constituting links between scattered geographies and contradictory and simultaneous histories; and with justice in the application of international human rights law.


ARAD, S. 2004. Paul Goldman Press Photographer, 1943–1961. Tel Aviv: Eretz Israel Museum.
AZOULAY, A. 1994. With Open Doors: Museum and Historical Narratives in Israel’s Public Space. In: SHERMAN, D. & ROGOFF, I. (eds.) Museum Culture: Histories, Discourse, Spectacles. London: Routledge.
AZOULAY, A. 2001. Death’s Showcase: The Power of Image in Contemporary Democracy, Cambridge, Mass., London, Trans. R. Danieli, MIT Press.
BENDER, B. & WINER, M. (eds.) 2001. Contested Landscapes: Movement, Exile and Place, Oxford and New York: Berg.
BENJAMIN, W. (ed.) 1973. Illuminations, London: Fontana.
BUCK-MORSS, S. 2000. Dreamworld and Catastrophe: The Passing of Mass Utopia in East and West, Cambridge, Mass. and London, England, MIT Press.
BUTLER, J. 2004. Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence, London, Verso.
BUTLER, J. 2005. Photography, War, Outrage. Modern Language Association of America, 120, 823. doi:
CADAVA, E. 1997. Words of Light: Theses on the Photography of History, Princeton, Princeton University Press.
COOK, J. 2006. Kidnapped by Israel: The British Media and the Invasion of Gaza. Medialens [Online]. Available:
EISENSTEIN, Z. 2004. Against Empire: Feminisms, Racism and the West, London and New York, Zed Books.
GILERMAN, D. 2005. Tumarkin is Not the Only One Missing from the List’. Ha’aretz [Online]. Available:
IRIN, 2007. One-third of Palestinians ‘food insecure’. [online] Available at:
KESHET, Y. K. 2006. Checkpoint Watch: Testimonials from Occupied Palestine, London and New York, Zed Books.
KHOURY, E. 2005. Gate of the Sun; Bab El Shams, London, Trans. H. Davies, Harvill Secker.
KRATSMAN, M. 2004. Machsom. In: HON, G. (ed.) What Remains to be Seen: Art and Political Conflict: Views from Britain, Israel, Palestine and Northern Ireland. London: Multi Exposure.
LESCH, A. 1991. Palestine: A Photographic Journey, Berkeley, University of California Press.
MARTIN-GROPIUS-BAU. 2005. A Brief Introduction to the “clusters”, of the exhibition
“The New Hebrews: A Century of Art in Israel”, Press Material, Berlin.
MASALHA, N. 2000. Imperial Israel and the Palestinians: The Politics of Expansion, London, Pluto Press.
MITCHELL, W. J. T. 2006. Christo’s Gates and Gilo’s Walls. Critical Inquiry, 32, 590. doi: and
NIR, Y. 2004. Paul Goldman: Homage to a Press Photographer. Paul Goldman Press Photographer, 1943–1961. Tel Aviv: Eretz Israel Museum.
SAID, E. 1975. Beginnings: Intention and Method, New York, Basic Books Inc.
SAID, E. 1996. Palestine: Memory, Invention and Space. In: ABU-LUGHOD, I., HEACOCK, R. & NASHEF, K. (eds.) The Landscape of Palestine: Equivocal Poetry. Birzeit, Palestine: Birzeit University Publications.
SHALOM, S. R. (ed.) 2007. Perilous Power: The Middle East and US Foreign Policy: Dialogues in Terror, Democracy, War and Justice, Boulder, Co and London: Paradigm Publishers.
SELA, R. 2006. Vom “goldenen Jerusalem” zum “brennenden Tel-Aviv”. Von der zionistischen zur kritischen Fotographie’ (‘From “golden Jerusalem” to “burning Tel-Aviv”: From Zionist to critical photography), in Die Neuen Hebraer: 100 Yahre Kunst in Israel (The New Hebrews: 100 Years of Art in Israel), Martin-Gropius-Bau, Berlin.
SONTAG, S. 1978. On Photography, London, Allen Lane Penguin Books.
SONTAG, S. 2004. Regarding the Pain of Others, London, Penguin.
WEISS, M. 2002. The Chosen Body: The Politics of the Body in Israeli Society, Stanford, Stanford University Press.
WEIZMAN, E. 2007. Hollow Land: Israel’s Architecture of Occupation, London, Verso.
WOODALL, J. 2005. Creation of a Nation. Financial Times, 13 May.
YIFTACHEL, O. 2002. Territory as the Kernel of the Nation: Space, Time and Nationalism in Israel/Palestine. Geopolitics, 7, 227. doi:
ZADKA, R. M. 2003. The ‘Transparent’ Wall in Jerusalem’s Gilo Neighbourhood. MA, University of Leeds in Israel.
ZANGER, A. 2005. Blind Space: Roadblock Movies in Contemporary Israeli Film. Shofar: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Jewish Studies, 24, 39. doi:
ZERTAL, I. 2000. From the People’s Hall to the Wailing Wall: A Study in Memory, Fear and War. Representations, 69, 113. doi:
ZERUBAVEL, Y. 1995. Recovered Roots: Collective Memory and the Making of Israeli National Tradition, Chicago and London, University of Chicago Press.
ZERUBAVEL, Y. 2002. The “Mythological Sabra” and Jewish Past: Trauma, Memory, and Contested Identities. Israel Studies, 7, 117. doi: and