From Starbucks to Carrefour: Consumer Boycotts, Nationalism and Taste in Contemporary China

Pál Nyíri


Abstract

In the 2000s, China has witnessed a series of consumer boycott campaigns, some of which received nationwide publicity, and one of which, the campaign against the French discounter chain Carrefour in 2008, produced street pickets. The motivation behind these campaigns has been largely nationalistic, as the brands or companies targeted were deemed to offend China. This article sketches the dynamics of consumer boycotts and asks whether, beyond being a vehicle of nationalism, the emerging politics of consumption is also becoming a tool of expressing taste.

Keywords

China; nationalism; consumption; Internet; boycotts; social movements; taste

References

Adler, C. 2003, 'Colonel Sanders' March on China, ' Time, 17 November.

Ai de zhongdian ('End of love'). 2008, 'Bali, ni da le ziji de erguang!' (Paris, You Slapped Your Own Face). Online, available: www.chinaren.com, 11 April. http://club.chinaren.com/120937688.html (accessed 28 April 2008).

Barm, G. 1999, In the Red, Columbia University Press, New York.

Dong, L. & Tian, K. 2009, . 'The Use of Western Brands in Asserting Chinese National Identity, ' Journal of Consumer Research, no. 36, no page numbers.

EastSouthWestNorth. 2008. 'Daily Brief Comments April 11-20, 2008.' Online, available: http://zonaeuropa.com/200804b.brief.htm (accessed 28 April 2008).

Fang Ning, Wang Xiaodong & Song Qiang (eds). 1999, Quanqiuhua yinmou xia de Zhongguo zhi lu (China's Road in the Globalization Conspiracy), Zhongguo Shehui Kexue Chubanshe, Beijing.

'Forbidden City Caf.' 2007, China Daily, 24 September.

French, H. W. 2006, 'Online Throngs Impose a Stern Morality in China, ' New York Times, 3 June.

Garver, J.W. 2001, 'More from the 'Say No Club, '' The China Journal, no. 45, 152-58.

Gerth, K. 2003, China Made: Consumer Culture and the Creation of the Nation, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.

Guangming Ribao. 2007a, 'You Xingbake kan wenwu huanjing de baohu' (Through Starbucks, Looking at the Protection of Cultural Monuments' Surroundings), 18 January. Online, available: http://news.sina.com.cn/o/2007-01-18/060511027554s.shtml (accessed 5 February 2007).

Guangming Ribao. 2007b, 'Zhuanjia jiaofeng Xingbake kaijin Gugong, "' (Experts Discuss Forbidden City Starbucks), 18 January. Online, available: http://www.sina.com.cn/o/2007-01-18/060511027555s.shtml (accessed 4 February 2007)."

Han Han. 2008, 'Huida aiguozhe de wenti' (Answers to Patriots' Questions), 24 April. Online, available: http://bbs.book.sina.com.cn/tableforum/App/newreply.php?bbsid=9 & subid=0 & act=quote & fid=31 2058 & replyid=21481 & ftitle=%BB%D8%B4%F0%B0%AE%B9%FA%D5%DF%B5%C4%CE% CA%CC%E2 & tbid=3919 & jump=4 (accessed 29 April 2008).

Huashangbao. 2008, 'Gongshang bumen diaocha guiqi guanggao Maidanglao shou xunwen' (Industry and Trade Organs Investigated Begging Ad; Inquiry Targets McDonalds). Online, available: http://info.hotel.hc360.com/2005/06/21201545305.shtml (accessed 16 May 2006).

Jing, Jun. 2000, Feeding China's Little Emperors: Food, Children, and Social Change, Stanford University Press, Stanford.

Kafei. 2004, 'Zhongguo long 'hua' dao zai Libang qi xia, guoren paoxiao yaoqiu Libang Qi daoqian' (Chinese Dragon Slides" on Nippon Lacquer; Our Countrymen Loudly Demand Nippon's Apology, ' Jinlu Wanbao, 23 September. Online, available: http://news.tom.com/1006/2004923-1351387.html (accessed 16 May 2006)."

Lao Chu. 2007, 'Kendeji, mo yakualiao Zhongguo wa' (KFC, You Can't Daunt the Chinese Baby), 7 March. Online, available: http://www.tianya.cn/new/publicforum/content.asp?idarticle=63298 & stritem=no06 & idwriter=1141 1235 & key=932756149 & flag=1 (accessed 7 March 2007).

Li Hongmei. 2008, 'Branding Chinese Products: Between Nationalism and Transnationalism, ' International Journal of Communication, no. 2, 1125-63.

Li Yanjun. 2006, 'Ying le zunyan zhong le quantao' (Won Respect, Got into a Trap), Yingxiao Chuanqi. Online, available: http://www.cnyxcq.com/news (accessed 16 May 2006).

Lu, Xinyu. 2009, 'Ritual, Television, and State Ideology: Rereading CCTV's 2006 Spring Festival Gala, ' in TV China, (eds) C. Berry & Ying Zhu, Indiana University Press, Bloomington, 111-128.

Mo Zhixu. 2008, 'Wo weishenme fandui dizhi' (Why I Oppose the Boycott), Zhongguo Xinwen Zhoukan, reproduced on Sina.com.cn, 23 April. Online, available: http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2008-04-23/090815412541.shtml (accessed 2 May 2008).

Modern Weekly / Zhoumo Huabao. 2008. 'Ai, zeren yu gongxian' (Love, Responsibility, and Contribution) (advertisement), Lifestyle (Shenghuo) section, 12-13 July, C50.

Mu Rong Zhu Ning. 2007, 'Yelu shijie xuezhe bing bu quefa baorongxin' (Global Yale Scholar Does Not Lack a Sense of Inclusiveness), 17 January. Online, available: http://blog.sina.com.cn/u/4b28fe01010007n9 (accessed 20 January 2007).

Netease. 2005, 'Shanghai shi jiaowei jiaoyanshi yinyuejiao yanyuan Wang Yueping: Dui xuesheng you hen hao de jiaoyu yiyi' (Wang Yueping, Music Education Researcher at Shanghai Education Commission's Education Research Laboratory: It's Very Educational for Students), 15 March. Online, available: http://news.163.com/05/0315/05/1ES402QF0001122B.html (accessed 2 April 2007).

Beijing Qingnianbao, 25 June.

Wang, Jian. 2006, 'The Politics of Goods: A Case Study of Consumer Nationalism and Media Discourse in Contemporary China, ' Asian Journal of Communication, vol. 16, no. 2: 187-206. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/01292980600638710

Wang, Jian & Zhiying Wang. 2007, 'The Political Symbolism of Business. Exploring Consumer Nationalism and its Implications for Corporate Reputation Management in China, ' Journal of Communication Management, vol. 11, no. 2, 134-49. http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/13632540710747361

Wang Xiaodong. 2005, 'Chinese Nationalism Under the Shadow of Globalization, ' speech at the London School of Economics and Political Science, 7 February.

Watts, J. 2007, 'Starbucks Faces Eviction from the Forbidden City, ' The Guardian, 18 January.

Xinhua. 2004, 'Badao" qiche guanggao re zhong nu Fengtian xiang wo guo xiaofeizhe zhiqian' (Prado Car Ad Provokes Mass Anger; Toyota Apologises to Our Country's Customers), 23 September. Online, available: http://news.tom.com/1006/2004923-1351626.html (accessed 16 May 2006)."

Xinhuanet. 2008, 'Jiang Yu: Fafang ying dui Zhongguo minzhong yijian he qingxu jinxing fansi' (Jiang Yu: French Side Should Think about Opinion and Emotions of Chinese Masses), 15 April. Online, available: http://news.xinhuanet.com/newscenter/2008-04/15/content_7981786.htm (accessed 2 May 2008).

Xin Jing Bao. 2007, 'Yi lixing taidu kandai Gugong Xingbake' (Looking Rationally at the Forbidden City Starbucks), 17 january. Online, available: http://news.sina.com.cn/c/pl/2007-01-17/091712059724.shtml (accessed 4 February 2007).

Xu Weicheng. 1995, Speech at the National Audiovisual Publishing Work Conference, 21 December, in 'Guanyu yinfa Xu Weicheng, Yu Youxian tongzhi zai Quanguo yinxiang chuban gongzuo Huiyi shang jianghua de tongzhi' (Notice on the Printing and Distribution of the Speeches of Comrades Xu Weicheng and Yu Youxian at the National Audiovisual Publishing Work Conference), General Administration of Press and Publication document [1996], 121.

Yang Lili. 2004, 'Libang Qichan guanggao zhong panlong hualuo" huamian yinqi zhengyi' ('Sliding Dragon' Frame in Libang Lacquer Factory Ad Triggers Controversy), reproduced on news.tom.com from Beijing Chenbao, 23 September. Online, available: http://news.tom.com/4005/4411/4413/20040923-1349567.html (accessed 16 May 2006)."

Zhang Xiong & Chen Xuan. 2008, 'Zhongguoshi fennu: yi chang chaohu xiangxiang de dizhi' (Rage Chinese Style: A Boycott that Exceeded Expectations), Xin Shiji Zhoukan, reproduced on Sina.com.cn, 28 April. Online, available: Http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2008-04-28/140615443763.shtml (accessed 4 May 2008).

Zhao, Suisheng. 2008, 'The Olympics and Chinese Nationalism, ' China Security, vol. 4, no. 3, 48-57.

Zhong Chengxiang. 2003, 'Xin de minzu qingdian, mei de wenhua da can' (A New Folk Celebration, A Beautiful Cultural Feast), Renmin Ribao, 11 February, 14.

Zhongguo Xinwen Zhoukan. 2008, 'Weishenme dizhi Jialefu' (Why Boycott Carrefour), 23 April. Online, available: http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2008-04-23/090815412532.shtml (accessed 2 May 2008).

Zhou Qing'an. 2007, 'Xingbake neng fou banchu Zhongguoren xinling de Gugong' (Can Starbucks Move Out of the Forbidden City in Chinese People's Minds?), Nanfang Dushibao, 17 January. Online, available: http://www.sina.com.cn/c/pl/2007-01-17/090012059215.shtml (accessed 4 February 2007).