Contesting realities

Jessica Whyte


In 2004, an unnamed Bush adviser accused a senior Wall Street Journal reporter of belonging to the “reality based
community”—a community that believed solutions stem from the judicious study of reality. “We're history's actors, “ he told the journalist, “and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do.” Overwhelmingly, the response of those on the left, and of US progressives to this comment was to smugly deride the irrationalism and the arrogance of the Bush Administration. This paper, in contrast, will examine what is missed in the rush to accept membership of the reality based community. It will suggest that that the advisor's comments express something that was once a central tenet of the left: the belief that political action is capable of transforming reality. Today, on the left, this belief has been all but abandoned in the face of a seemingly unstoppable onslaught of free market capitalism and increasingly repressive state power. This paper will ask what it would mean today, to begin to re-imagine political action as capable of remaking the world.

Full Text:



AAP 2006a, 'Bush Praises Saddam Verdict', USA Today, November 6, <> .

AAP 2006b, 'Saddam Trial Heroic Says Howard', The Age, November 6, < >.

Adorno, T. 1973, Negative Dialectics, Continuum, London.

Agamben, G. 2000, Means Without Ends: Notes on Politics, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.

Benjamin, W. 1985, 'On the Critique of Violence', in, One Way Street and Other Writings, Verso, London.

Benjamin, W. 1999, 'The work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction', in H. Arendt (ed.), Illuminations, Harcourt, Brace and World, London.

Benjamin, W. 2003, 'On the Concept of History', in, Selected Writings, vol. 4, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass

Brown, W. 2006, 'Learning to Love Again: An Interview With Wendy Brown', Contretemps, 6th January.

Bush, G. 1991, 'Speech to Congress, 6th March', <> .

Bush, G.W. 2002, 'Remarks by the President at 2002 Graduation Exercise of the United States Military Academy, West Point, New York, 1 June', The West Point Speech, <> .

Bush, G.W. 2007, 'State of the Union Address', <> .

Dougherty, H. 2001, 'War May Not be Over in Our Lifetime, Warns Cheney', Irish Examiner, October 22nd, <> .

Pilkington, E. 2009, 'Obama Under Fire for Guantanamo Trials', The Age, May 17.

Suskind, R. 2004, 'Without a Doubt', The New York Times, October 17, <> .

Wolfowitz, P. 2003, 'Excerpts from 1992 Defence Planning Guidance', Frontline, <> .



Share this article: