Soil Governance: Accessing Cross-Disciplinary Perspectives

Tanya Marjoram Howard
Andrew Lawson

Abstract


Soil provides the foundation for agricultural and environmental systems, and are subject to a complex governance regime of property rights and secondary impacts from industry and domestic land use. Complex natural resource management issues require approaches to governance that acknowledge uncertainty and complexity. Theories of next generation environmental governance assume that inclusion of diverse perspectives will improve reform directions and encourage behaviour change. This paper reports on a qualitative survey of an international workshop that brought together cross-disciplinary perspectives to address the challenges of soil governance. Results reveal the challenges of communicating effectively across disciplines. The findings suggest that strategies for improved soils governance must focus on increasing communications with community stakeholders and engaging land managers in designing shared governance regimes. The need for more conscious articulation of the challenges of cross-disciplinary environments is discussed and strategies for increasing research collaboration in soils governance are suggested. The identified need for more systematic approaches to cross-disciplinary learning, including reporting back of cross-disciplinary initiatives to help practitioners learn from past experience, forms part of the rationale for this paper.


Full Text:

PDF HTML

References

Allan, Catherine,'Can Adaptive Management Help us Embrace the Murray-Darling Basin’s Wicked Problems?' in Claudia Pahl-Wostl, Pavel Kabat and Jörn Möltgen (eds), Adaptive and Integrated Water Management (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2008) 61

Arnalds, Andres, 'Farmers Heal the Land: A Social License for Agriculture in Iceland' in Jacqueline Williams and Paul Martin (eds), Defending the Social License of Farming: Issues, Challenges and New Directions for Agriculture (CSIRO publishing, 2011) 83

Aslin, Heather, and Kirsty Blackstock, ''Now I'm not an expert in anything': challenges in undertaking transdisciplinary inquiries across the Social and Biophysical sciences' in Valerie A Brown, A Harris, Jacqueline Y Russell (eds), Tackling wicked problems through the transdisciplinary imagination (Earthscane, 2010).

Bammer, G, 'Strengthening Interdisciplinary Research: What it is, What it Does, How it Does it and How it is Supported' (Report for the Australian Council of Learned Academies, Melbourne, 2012)

Beierle, Thomas C, 'Using Social Goals to Evaluate Public Participation in Environmental Decisions' (1999) 16(3-4) Review of Policy Research 75, 77

Bernard, H R, and G W Ryan, Analysing Qualitative Data: Systematic Approaches (Sage, 2010); W L Neuman, Social Research Methods (Allyn and Bacon, 7th ed, 2011)

Borrini-Feyerabend G, et al, A Primer on Governance for Protected and Conserved Areas (IUCN, 2014)

Brown, Valerie, 'Conducting an Imaginative Transdisciplinary Inquiry' in Valerie A Brown, John A Harris and Jacqueline Y Russell (eds), Tackling Wicked Problems Through the Transdisciplinary Imagination (Earthscan, 2010).

Brugnach, M, et al, 'More is not Always Better: Coping with Ambiguity in Natural Resources Management' (2011) 92(1) Journal of Environmental Management 78

Campbell, A, 'Managing Australia's Soils: A Policy Discussion Paper’ (Prepared for the National Committee on Soil and Terrain (NCST) through the Natural Resource Management Ministerial Council (NRMMC), 2008), <http://www.clw.csiro.au/aclep/documents/Soil-Discussion-Paper.pdf>

Croft, Roger, Healing the Land: The Story of Land Reclamation and Soil Conservation in Iceland (Soil Conservation Service of Iceland 2011, 2011)

Dellinger, Marianne, 'Ten Years of the Aarhus Convention: How Procedural Democracy Is Paving the Way for Substantive Change in National and International Environmental Law' (2012) 23(2) Colorado Journal of International Environmental Law & Policy 309.

Diamond, Jared, Collapse: How Scoeities Choose to Fail or Succeed (Viking Penguin, 2005)

Dovers, Steve, 'Embedded Scales: Interdisciplinary and Institutional Issues' in Valerie Brown, John Harris and Jacqueline Russel (eds), Tackling Wicked Problems Through the Transdisciplinary Imagination (Earthscan Ltd, 2010)

Evans, Mark and Richard Reid, 'Public Participation in an Era of Governance: lessons from Europe for Australian Local Government' (Australian Centre of Excellence for Local Government, 2014) <http://apo.org.au/node/38341>

Eversole, Robyn, 'Community Agency and Community Engagement: Re-theorising Participation in Governance' (2011) 31(1) Journal of Public Policy 51; Frank Fischer, Citizens, Experts and the Environment: The Politics of Local Knowledge (Duke University Press, 1st ed, 2005)

FAO, Intergovernmental Technical Panel on Soils (‘ITPS’)(2015) Global Soils Partnership <http://www.fao.org/globalsoilpartnership/intergovernmental-technical-panel-on-soils/en/>

FAO, The 5 Pillars of Action (2015) Global Soil Partnership <http://www.fao.org/globalsoilpartnership/the-5-pillars-of-action/en/>

Fischer, Frank, Citizens, Experts and the Environment: The Politics of Local Knowledge (Duke University Press, 1st ed, 2005)

Fisher, Elizabeth, et al, 'Maturity and Methodology: Starting a Debate About Environmental Law Scholarship' (2009) 21(2) Journal of Environmental Law 213; Neef and Neubert, above n 25

Fitzsimons, James, and Geoff Wescott, 'The Importance of Interdisciplinary Research in Conservation Networks: Lessons from South-Eastern Australia' in Ian Pulsford, James Fitzsimons and Geoff Wescott (eds), Linking Australia's Landscapes: Lessons and Opportunities from Large-Scale Conservation Networks (CSIRO publishing, 2013)

Hendriks, Carolyn, 'Inclusive Governance for Sustainability' in Valerie Brown, John Harris and Jacqueline Russel (eds), Tackling Wicked Problems Through the Transdisciplinary Imagination (Earthscan Ltd, 2010)

Herriman, Jade, 'Local Government and Community Engagement in Australia' (Working Paper No 5, Australian Centre of Excellence for Local Government, University of Technology, 2011)

Hillel, Daniel, Out of the Earth: Civilization and the Life of the Soil (Free Press, 1991)

Hillman, Terry, et al, 'Multidisciplinary Approaches to Natural Resource Management' (2005) 552(1) Hydrobiologia 99

Holley, Cameron, 'Public Participation, Environmental Law and New Governance: Lessons for Designing Inclusive and Representative Participatory Processes' (2010) 27(5) Environmental and Planning Law Journal 32

Joffe, Helene, 'Thematic Analysis' in D Harper and A R Thompson (eds), Qualitative Research Methods in Mental Health and Psychotherapy: A Guide for Students and Practitioners (John Wiley and Sons, 1st ed, 2012)

Killham, K, 'Foresight Project on Global Food and Farming Futures - Integrated Soil Management - Moving Towards Globally Sustainable Agriculture' (2011) 149 Journal of Agricultural Science (2011) 29; and Weigelt et al, above n 10

Koch, Andrea, et al, 'Soil Security: Solving the Global Soil Crisis' (2013) 4(4) Global Policy 434

Maier, H R, et al, 'Uncertainty in Environmental Decision Making: Issues, Challenges and Future Directions' in A A Voinov, A E Rizzoli, A Jakeman and S H Chen (eds), Developments in Integrated Environmental Assessment (Elsevier, vol 3, 2008) 69

Montgomery, R David, Dirt: The Erosion of Civilizations (University of California Press, 2007); Jared Diamond, Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed (Viking Penguin, 2005)

Neef, Andreas, and Dieter Neubert, 'Stakeholder Participation in Agricultural Research Projects: A Conceptual Framework for Reflection and Decision-Making' (2011) 28(2) Agriculture and Human Values 179

Neuman, W L, Social Research Methods (Allyn and Bacon, 7th ed, 2011)

Ponting, Clive, A Green History of the World: The Environment and the Collapse of Great Civilizations (Penguin, 1991)

Ryan, S, et al, 'Australia’s NRM Governance System: Foundations and Principles for Meeting Future Challenges' (2010) <http://www.actnrmcouncil.org.au/node/193>

Strang, Veronica, 'Integrating the social and natural sciences in environmental research: a discussion paper' (2009) 11(1) Environment, Development and Sustainability 1

Taft, Kevin, 'Fossil Fuels, Global Warming and Democracy: A Report from a Scene of the Collision' (University of Western Sydney, 2014) <http://apo.org.au/node/41234>

van der Heijden, Marcel G A, Richard D Bardgett and Nico M van Straalen, 'The Unseen Majority: Soil Microbes as Drivers of Plant Diversity and Productivity in Terrestrial Ecosystems' (2008) 11 Ecology Letters 296

Weigelt, Jes, et al, 'Towards Integrated Governance of Land and Soil: Addressing Challenges and Moving Ahead’ (Issue Paper, Global Economic Symposium, 2012) <http://www.global-economic-symposium.org/knowledgebase/losing-ground/virtual-library/towards-integrated-governance-of-land-and-soil-addressing-challenges-and-moving-ahead.201d/at_download/file>

Workshop IDS, 'Participation, Policy Change and Empowerment' in J Holland and J Blackburn (eds), Whose Voice? Participatory Research and Policy Change (Intermediate Technology Publications, 1998) 192



PDF HTML


DOI: https://doi.org/10.5130/ijrlp.i1.2015.3776

Share this article: