Imagining Exodus for Israel-Palestine: Reading the Secular and the Sacred, Diaspora and Homeland, in Edward Said and David Grossman

Anna Hartnell


Abstract

This paper takes as its starting point Edward Said's distinction between 'religious' and 'secular' modes of cultural affiliation. As these simultaneously diverging and converging modes also trammel the particular grounds of thinking that have been Said's natural target of criticism - Zionism - his work speaks particularly powerfully to the debate surrounding the religious genealogy of Jewish identity. This paper argues that Said's interventions on Zionism highlight as problematic the position whereby the 'Ingathering of the Exiles' is promoted as coexisting with a 'diasporic consciousness' nurtured by Judaism during exile; messianic hopes of religious Jews cannot be reconciled with physical return to the Promised Land; identity circumscribed by ethnicity and place cannot stand in as exemplary for the exiled, unsettled and ultimately homeless identity trumpeted by discourses of the 'post', as many contemporary theorists would have it. And yet through an exploration of the writings of David Grossman, whose construction of Jewish identity is envisaged through the regulating, competing and collaborating tropes of Zionism and Diaspora, I argue that this position is crucial for the elaboration of Israeli identity. I also argue that in fact there is room within Said's thinking both for the anti-essentialist elaboration of 'homeless' identities as well as 'the permission to narrate' an identity politics, and that his own distinction between the 'secular' and the 'religious' begins to disassemble. I explore this blurring of the sacred and the secular through the prism of Exodus - as both concept and narrative. This paper suggests that it is precisely Said's achievement to embody these tensions between religion and its other, divine providence and human agency, historical materialism and postmodernism, alienation and its perennially tempting opposite: home.

Keywords

Religion; Exodus; Diaspora; Israel; Palestine; Postmodernism

Full Text

PDF

References

Aloni, U., 2004, Local Angel: Theological Political Fragments, trans. Howard Cohen, ICA, London.

Avineri, S., 1981, The Making of Modern Zionism: The Intellectual Origins of the Jewish State, Weidenfeld and Nicholson, London.

Bayoumi, M & A. Rubin, A (eds.), The Edward Said Reader, Granta, London.

Boyarin, D. & J, Boyarin, 1995, 'The Double Mark of the Jew', Rhetorics of Self Making, ed. D. Battaglia, University of California Press, Berkley.

Budick, S. & G. Hartman, (ed.), 1986, Midrash and Literature, Yale University Press, New Haven & London.

Caputo, J.D., 1997, The Prayers and Tears of Jacques Derrida, Indiana University Press, Bloomington & Indianapolis.

Cleary, J., 2002, Literature, Partition and the Nation State, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511483110

Cohen, J., 1990, Voices of Israel, State University of New York Press, Albany.

Dan, J., 1992, 'Scholem's View of Jewish Messianism' in Modern Judaism, vol.2, 119-126.

Derrida, J., 1986, Glas, trans. J P Leavey, Jr, & R Rand, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln & London.

Derrida, J., 2002, Acts of Religion, Routledge, New York & London.

Dooley, M., 2001, The Politics of Exodus, Fordham University Press, New York.

Grossman, D., 1988, The Yellow Wind, trans. Haim Watzman, Picador, New York.

Grossman, D.(ed.) 1998, The Second Book of Moses, called Exodus, authorised King James Version with an introduction by David Grossman, Canongate, Edinburgh.

Grossman, D., 1999, See Under: Love, trans. Betty Rosenberg, Vintage, London.

Gunkel, D., 1998, 'Escape Velocity: Exodus and Postmodernism', Soundings, vol. 81, no.3-4: 437-459.

Handelman, S., 1982, The Slayers of Moses, University of New York Press, Albany.

Hart, W., 2000, Edward Said and the Religious Effects of Culture, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511488412

Leibowitz, Y., 1992, Judaism, Human Values, and the Jewish State, trans. Eliezer Goldman, Harvard University Press, Cambridge Massachusetts & London.

Rose, J., 1996, States of Fantasy, Oxford University Press, Oxford & New York.

Said, E., 1983, The World, the Text, and the Critic, Harvard University Press, Cambridge Massachusetts

Said, E., 1988, 'Michael Walzer's Exodus and Revolution: A Caananite Reading', in Blaming the Victims: Spurious Scholarship and the Palestinian Question, eds. C Hitchen & Edward Said, Verso, London & New York

Said, E., 2000, Reflections on Exile, Granta Books, London.

Said, E., 2003, Freud and the Non-European, Verso, London & New York.

Scholem, G., 1971, The Messianic Idea in Judaism Shocken Books, New York

Shlaim, A., 2000, The Iron Wall, Penguin Books, London & New York

Sicher, E., (ed.), 1998, Breaking Crystal: Writing and Memory after Auschwitz, University of Illinois Press, Urbana & Chicago.

Walzer, M., 1985, Exodus and Revolution, Basic Books, New York.

Zornberg, A. G., 1996, Genesis: The Beginning of Desire, The Jewish Publication Society, Jerusalem & Philedelphia.