From the Stereotypification of the Non-European Other to the Prototypification of the European Self: A Case Study of Turkey’s Membership to the European Union from the French Perspective.

Ariane Bogain, Florence Potot

Abstract


In an era of increased globalisation, the need for a sense of belonging and an identity is becoming more pressing. The way nations form images of others and, conversely, conscious or unconscious images of themselves is becoming increasingly important as these images impact on public opinion and on political and decision-making discourse. With the development of supranationalism in Europe, the age-old notion of European identity has come more and more to the fore. Conflicting interpretations and a general disinclination to consider the matter leave the notion of European identity as polysemic as ever. Furthermore, the expansion of the EU has contributed to blurring this notion, so much so that in the collective psyche, it has become closely linked to the membership of the European Union and it is proving sometimes difficult to dissociate one from the other. In this context, the debate surrounding Turkey’s membership of the EU gives an insight into prototypical and stereotypical representations of Europe.


As the controversy has been particularly salient in France, the aim of this study is to explore the European self-conceptions and images of the other through the example of France’s opposition to Turkey’s membership of the EU. For this purpose, opinion polls and the Press will be used as forms of narrative in order to highlight these representations and how they have evolved in time. The first part of the study will concentrate on the arguments put forward to justify the opposition to Turkey joining the EU. The second part will then evaluate how the image of the other contributes to the prototypical representation French citizens have of Europe.

Keywords


European Union; Europeanness; Stereotypification; Prototypification; Turkey; Enlargement

Full Text:

PDF

References


Amossy, R., & Herschberg-Pierrot, A. 2004, Strotypes et Clichs, Nathan, Paris. Badinter, R. 2005, 'Avec la Turquie, l'Europe Renonce, ' Le Monde [Online]. Available: http://www.lemonde.fr/web/article/0, 1-0, 36-698845, 0.html [Accessed: 20 Apr. 2006].

De Bresson, H. 2004, 'Jusqu'o repousser les frontires de l'Europe?, ' Le Monde [Online]. Available: http://abonnes.lemonde.fr/web/article_theme/0, 42-0@2-3214, 36-364746@53-7646, 0.html [Accessed: 27 June 2006].

Deutsch, K, Burrell, S.A., Kahn, R.A., Lee, M., Lichterman, M., Lindgren, R.E, Loewenheim, F. & Wagenen, R.W. 1957, Political Community and the North Atlantic Area: International Organization in Light of Historical Experience, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.

Dubois, D. & Resche-Rigon, P. 1993, 'Prototypes ou Strotypes: Productivit et figement d'un concept, ' in Lieux Communs, Topoi, Strotypes, Clichs, ed. C. Plantin, Kim, Paris. Pp372-389.

Duhamel, A. 2002, 'La realpolitik d'Hubert Vdrine, ' Libration, 14 Dec., 43.

Cautrs, B. 2003, 'Le CNRS l'heure de l'Europe, ' Thma CNRS, no. 1.

Clerc, P. 2002, 'Turquie: La Gographie Prtexte, ' Le Monde [Online]. Available: http://abonnes.lemonde.fr/web/article/0, 1-0@2-3232, 36-298538, 0.html [Accessed : 25 Apr. 2006]. Eichenberg, R.C. & Dalton, R.J. 1993, 'Europeans and the European Community: The Dynamics of Public Support for European Integration, ' International Organization, vol.47, no. 4, 50734. European Commission 2002, L'Opinion Publique dans l'Union Europeenne- Eurobaromtre 58 [Online].Available: http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/standard_fr.htm [Accessed: 10 Apr. 2006]. 2003a, L'largissement de l'Union Europenne Flash Eurobaromtre 140 [Online].Available: http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/archives/flash_arch_fr.htm [Accessed: 10 Apr. 2006]. 2003b, L'Opinion Publique dans l'Union Europeenne- Eurobaromtre 60 [Online].Available: http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/standard_fr.htm [Accessed: 10 Apr. 2006]. 2004, L'Opinion Publique dans l'Union Europeenne- Eurobaromtre 62 [Online].Available: http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/standard_fr.htm [Accessed: 10 Apr. 2006]. 2005, L'Opinion Publique dans l'Union Europeenne- Eurobaromtre 64 [Online].Available: http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/standard_fr.htm [Accessed: 10 Apr. 2006].

Clerc, P. 2006a, Quelle Europe? La Construction Europenne Vue par les Franais Flash Eurobaromtre 178 [Online]. Available: http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/archives/flash_arch_fr.htm [Accessed: 15 Apr. 2006].

Clerc, P. 2006b, Le futur de l'Europe Flash Eurobaromtre 140 [Online]. Available: http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/archives/flash_arch_fr.htm [Accessed: 10 Apr. 2006].

Fishman, J. 1956, 'An Examination of the Process of Social Stereotyping, ' The Journal of Social Psychology, vol.43, 2764. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00224545.1956.9919199

Goulard, S. 2004, 'Le processus prmatur d'adhsion de la Turquie met en pril la cohrence europenne, ' Libration, 8 Oct., 35.

Harouel, J.L. 2005, 'Le Leg du Christianisme, ' Le Figaro, 5 Oct., 12.

Ifop 2005, Les Franais et l'Adhsion de la Turquie l'Union Europenne la Veille du Dbut des Ngociations [Online]. Available: http://www.ifop.com/europe/sondages/opinionf/turquie.asp [Accessed: 22 Apr. 2006].

Ipsos 2002, Les Franais et l'Adhsion de la Turquie l'Union Europenne [Online]. Available: http://www.ipsos.fr/CanalIpsos/poll/7703.asp [Accessed: 20 Apr. 2006].

Ipsos 2004, Les Franais et l'Adhsion de la Turquie l'Union Europenne [Online]. Available: http://www.ipsos.fr/CanalIpsos/poll/7980.asp [Accessed: 20 Apr. 2006].

Kleiber, G. 1990, La Smantique du Prototype, PUF, Paris.

Habermas, J. 1993, Justification and Application: Remarks on Discourse Ethics, trans. C.P. Cronin, MIT Press, Cambridge MA.

Laidi, Z. 2004, 'La Turquie face l'identit europenne, ' Libration, 20 Dec., 8.

Le Monde 2004, La Turquie appartient-elle l'Europe. Le Monde Thmatique [Online]. Available: http://abonnes.lemonde.fr/web/thematique/0, 42-0@2-3214, 53-7646, 0.html. [ Accessed: 30 June 2006.]

Louis-Harris 2004, Les Franais, l'Entre de la Turquie dans l'Union Europenne et le Gnocide Armnien [Online]. Available: http://www.lh2.fr/_upload/ressources/sondages/europe/lhfaypfmadhe9siondelaturquie2324avril.pdf [Accessed: 25 Apr. 2006].

Louis-Harris 2005, Sondage Post-Electoral Rfrendum sur le Trait Constitutionnel Europen [Online]. Available: http://www.lh2.fr/_upload/ressources/sondages/europe/LHFLibeiTeleReferPostElec30mai05.pdf [Accessed: 25 Apr. 2006].

Louis-Harris 2006, Le Baromtre Europen [Online]. Available: http://www.lh2.fr/_upload/ressources/sondages/europe/lh2artebaro_europeenavril06.pdf [Accessed: 25 Apr. 2006].

Mandraud, I 2005, Le processus d'adhsion de la Turquie L'UE avive les tensions au PS et droite. Le Monde[online] Available : http://abonnes.lemonde.fr/web/article_theme/0, 42-0@2-3224, 36-694803@53-694820, 0.html. [ Accessed: 27 June 2006.]

Mezri, H. 2004, 'Le marchand de tapis et la stripteaseuse, ' Libration, 31 Dec., 28.

Nachbar, J., and Lause, K. 1992, Popular Culture: An Introductory Text, Bowling Green University Press, Bowling Green

Onesta, G. 2005, 'Querelles Byzantines?' Carr D'Europe, 31 Oct., 1. .

Ramonet, I. 2004, 'Turquie, ' Le Monde Diplomatique, Nov., 1.

Renan, E. 1997, Qu'est-ce qu'une Nation?, Mille et une nuits, Paris.

Sjursen, H.2002, 'Why Expand? The Question of Legitimacy and Justification in the EU's Enlargement Policy, ' Journal of Common Market Studies, vol.40, n?3, 491-513.

TNS-Sofres 2004, Les Franais et l'Europe [Online]. Available: http://www.tns-sofres.com/etudes/pol/240504_europe_n.htm [Accessed: 15 Apr. 2006].

TNS-Sofres 2005a, Les Europeens et l'Adhsion de l'Ukraine l'Union Europenne [Online]. Available: http://www.tns-sofres.com/etudes/pol/250305_ukraine_n.htm [Accessed: 15 Apr. 2006].

TNS-Sofres 2005b, L'Europe Vue par les Europens [Online]. Available: http://www.tns-sofres.com/etudes/pol/051005_europe_n.htm [Accessed: 15 Apr. 2006].

TNS-Sofres 2006, Quelle Europe ? La Construction Europenne Vue par les Franais [Online]. Available: http://www.tns-sofres.com/etudes/pol/170306_europe.htm [Accessed: 15 Apr. 2006].

Wieviorka, M. 2005, 'La Turquie, alibi du oui et du non, ' Libration, 14 Jun., 41.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5130/portal.v5i1.443