Is the Unspeakable Singable? The Ethics of Holocaust Representation and the Reception of Górecki's Symphony no.3

Alison Moore


Abstract

Debates about Holocaust representation have long been haunted by the idea that the enormity and intensity of human suffering in the events of World War Two are ‘unspeakable’. In many such statements the capacity for cognition and the ethical dimension of aestheticisation are blurred – the Holocaust is ‘unspeakable’ both in the sense of being impossible to imagine in its full horror, but also morally inappropriate as the subject of artistic production. But do all forms of cultural representation of the Holocaust fail in the same way as words or to the same degree, in the eyes of those who would judge their merits according the tenet of unspeakability? This paper considers one particularly renowned work Henryk Górecki’s symphony no. 3 (Symfonia pieśni żałosnych) of 1976, discussing how it mediated both the global politics of Holocaust representation and the recuperation of victimhood in postcommunist Poland. Górecki claimed a subjectivity of failure in response to the challenge of representing the events of World War Two and has insisted that the symphony is not about war but about sorrow. The vocal lyrics are nonetheless profoundly thematised around war suffering, and the Second World War in particular - events he approached with a musical language of epic, pathos and redemption. In framing the subject of his work, he emphasised a Polish national suffering that both eschewed mention of specifically targeted groups of victims, and beckoned to Polish folk and catholic traditions. This article presents a new hypothesis about the success of Górecki’s work by considering it in relation to the ethical debates about Holocaust empathic response that have occurred in relation to historiographic, literary and filmic representation.

Keywords

Henryk Górecki, Symphony of Sorrowful Songs, Holocaust aestheticisation, suffering and music

Full Text

PDF

References

Adorno, W. T. 1983, Prisms, trans. S. Weber Nicholsen & S. Weber. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.

Bartov, O. 1996, Murder in Our Midst: The Holocaust, Industrial Killing, and Representation. Oxford University Press, New York.

Burleigh, M. 2002, Germany Turns Eastwards: A Study of Ostforschung in the Third Reich. Pan, London.

Dean, C.J. 2004, The Fragility of Empathy After the Holocaust. Cornell University Press, Ithaca.

Finkelstein, N. 2001, The Holocaust Industry: Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering, 2nd edition. Verso, New York.

Friedlnder, S. 1984, Reflections of Nazism: An Essay on Kitsch and Death. Harper & Row, New York.

Grecki, H. M. 1992, Symphony No. 3, Symfonia piesni zalosnych (Symphony of sorrowful songs): opus 36, for soprano solo and orchestra. Boosey & Hawkes, London.

Grecki, H. M. 2003, 'Remarks on Performing the Third Symphony, ' trans. M. Trochimczyk, Polish Music Journal, vol. 6, no. 2. Online, available: http://www.usc.edu/dept/polish_music/PMJ/issue/6.2.03/GoreckiThird.html [accessed 12 April 2010].

Grecki, H. M. 2004, Symphony no. 3 (Symphony of Sorrowful Songs); Three Olden Style Pieces, CD. Zofia Kilanowicz: Soprano, Polish National Radio Symphony Orchestra; Antoni Wit: Conductor. Naxos Recording.

Grecki, H. M. 1992, Symphony no. 3 (Symfonia piesni zalosnych) CD. Dawn Upshaw: Soprano; London Sinfonietta; David Zinman: Conductor. Nonesuch Records.

Gross, J. T. 2006, Fear: Antisemitism in Poland After Auschwitz, An Essay in Historical Interpretation. Random House, New York.

'Henryk Gorecki: Symphony 3 Sorrowful Songs"' 2011, Amazon.com page. Online, available: http://www.amazon.com/Henryk-Gorecki-Symphony-Sorrowful-Songs/dp/B000005J1C [accessed August 20 2011]."

Howard, L. B. 1998, 'Motherhood, Billboard, and the Holocaust: Perceptions and Receptions of Grecki's Symphony No. 3, ' Musical Quarterly, vol. 82, no. 1: 131159. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mq/82.1.131

Jakelski, L. 2009, 'Grecki's Scontri and Avant-Garde Music in Cold-War Poland, ' The Journal of Musicology, vol. 26, no. 2: 205259. http://dx.doi.org/10.1525/jm.2009.26.2.205

Kent, J. 2004, Holocaust: A Music Memorial Film From Auschwitz. DVD. Exec: Peter Maniura. BBC2.

Kontarsky, M. 2001, Trauma Auschwitz: Zu Verarbeitungen des Nichtverarbeitbaren bei Peter Weiss, Luigi Nono und Paul Dessau. Pfau, Saarbrcken.

Kramer, J. D. 2002, 'Coming to Terms with Music as Protest and Remembrance: One Composer's Story, ' Current Musicology, no. 67/68: 195242. LaCapra, D. 1994, Representing the Holocaust: History, Theory and Trauma. Cornell University Press, Ithaca.

Kramer, J. D. 1997, 'Lanzmann's Shoah: Here There Is No Why, "' Critical Inquiry, vol. 23, no. 2: 231269." http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/448828

Kramer, J. D. 2000, Writing History, Writing Trauma. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.

Lang, B. 1990, Act and Idea in the Nazi Genocide. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Kramer, J. D. 2003, Holocaust Representation: Art Within the Limits of History and Ethics. John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.

Lanzmann, C. 1985, Shoah: An Oral History of the Holocaust: The Complete Text of the Film. Pantheon Books, New York.

Lanzmann, C 1990, 'Hier ist kein Warum, ' in Au sujet de Shoah, le film de Claude Lanzmann. Editions Belin, Paris, 2737.

Liberles, R. & Lyman, S. 1995, Salo Wittmayer Baron: Architect of Jewish History. University of New York Press, New York.

Opdyke, I. 1999, In My Hands: Memories of a Holocaust Rescuer. Alfred A. Knopf, New York.

Palmer, T. 2008, Grecki, Symphony no. 3 (Symfonia piesni zalosnych). DVD, NTSC, Tony Palmer Films.

Phayer, M. 2000, The Catholic Church and Nazi Germany. Da Capo, Cambridge, MA.

Pople, A. 1998, Messaien: Quatuor pour la fin du temps. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Rothberg, M. 2000, Traumatic Realism: The Demands of Holocaust Representation. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.

Rusbridger, A. 1993, 'The Pole Who Remains Apart, ' London Guardian, 13 Feb.: 5.

Schoenberg, A. 1951, A Survivor From Warsaw, Op. 46. Schirmer, London.

Sontag, S. 2003, Regarding the Pain of Others. Penguin, London.

'Sorry Story' 1993, London Evening Standard, 18 June: 82.

Steigmann-Gall, R. 2003, Holy Reich: Conceptions of Christianity, 19191945. Cambridge University Press, New York. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511818103

Steiner, G. 1967, Language and Silence. Prometheus, New York.

Steinlauf, M. 1997, Bondage to the Dead: Poland and the Memory of the Holocaust. Syracuse University Press, New York.

Stratton, J. 2007, 'Punk, Jews and the Holocaustthe English Story, ' Shofar: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Jewish Studies, vol. 26, no. 4: 124149. http://dx.doi.org/10.1353/sho.2007.0125

Tec, N. 1984, Dry Tears: The Story of a Lost Childhood. Oxford University Press, New York.

Tec, N. 1987, When Light Pierced the Darkness: Christian Rescue of Jews in Nazi-Occupied Poland. Oxford University Press, New York.

Teter, M. 1999, 'Review of Michael Steinlauf, Bondage to the Dead'. H-Judaic July. Online, available: http://www.h-net.org/reviews/showrev.php?id=3260 [Accessed 10 February 2010].

Thomas, A. 2005, Polish Music Since Symanowsky. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511482038

Thomas, A. 1997, Gorecki, Oxford Studies of Composers. Clarendon Press, Oxford.

'Top 10 Discs of the Decade' 2002, BBC Music Magazine, 1 Nov.: 2728.

Wlodarski, A. 2010, 'The Testimonial Aesthetics of Different Trains, ' Journal of the American Musicological Society, vol. 63, no. 1: 99141. http://dx.doi.org/10.1525/jams.2010.63.1.99

White, H. B. 1992, 'Historical Emplotment and the Problem of Truth, ' in Probing the Limits of Representation: Nazism and the Final Solution, (ed.) S. Friedlander. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 3753.

Zelizer, B. 2000, Remembering to Forget: Holocaust Memory through the Camera's Eye. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.