Empire, War and Nation: Heritage Management Perspectives from Canada and Malta

John Tunbridge

Abstract


This article offers recent insights on contested heritage from Canada and Malta. These contrasting geographical extremes span a range of heritage dissonances but share a common historical identity as successor states to the British Empire, entailing familiar postcolonial heritage equivocations. Dissonances between colonial and indigenous heritage meanings are discussed. The principal focus of the paper is the Empire at war, as an issue of heritage management in Ottawa, the capital of Canada, and in Malta; comparative insights are generated with resonance for other imperial successor states such as Australia, New Zealand and Singapore. In Ottawa the National Capital Commission is engaged in a delicate management of heritage evolution from the imperial past to the multicultural present, involving adjustment and diversification of heritage meanings in which the indigenous peoples and Canada's wartime/military history figure prominently. Malta's time-depth generates an embarrassment of heritage resources, necessitating choices as it moves from 'blue' seacoast to 'grey' heritage tourism; while earlier eras are favoured, the British imperial and military heritage is inescapable, especially the heroic shared defence of 1940-3, generating management issues over recency, postcoloniality, the naval legacy and the problem of marketing to the former enemy populations. Questions of whose heritage, using which resources of what period, for whose benefit and how managed, elicit a different range of answers in the two cases: British colonial heritage is too diverse to be value-generalised, and there is no single, immutable colonial template for postcolonial identity. However, the particular legacy of the Empire at war is notably formative in the evolution of succeeding national identities.

Keywords


heritage; dissonance; war; postcolonialism; Canada; Malta

Full Text:

PDF

References


ALLAN, G. & ANSON, C. 2005. The Role of the Museum in Creating Multi-Cultural Identities: Lessons from Canada, Lewiston, New York, Edwin Mellen Press.

ASHWORTH, G. J. & TUNBRIDGE, J. E. 2000. The Tourist-Historic City: Retrospect and Prospect of Managing the Heritage City, Oxford, Elsevier.

ASHWORTH, G. J. & TUNBRIDGE, J. E. 2005. Moving from blue to grey tourism: Reinventing Malta. Tourism Recreation Research, 30, 45-54. doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/02508281.2005.11081232

BONIFACE, P. & FOWLER, P. J. 1993. Heritage and Tourism in the Global Village, London, Routledge.

CASS, J. 2004. Egypt on steroids: Luxor Las Vegas and postmodern Orientalism. In: LASANSKY, D. M. & MCLAREN, B. (eds.) Architecture and Tourism: Perception, Performance and Place. Oxford/New York: Berg.

EDENSOR, T. & KOTHARI, U. 2004. Sweetening colonialism: A Mauritian themed resort. In: LASANSKY, D. M. & MCLAREN, B. (eds.) Architecture and Tourism: Perception, Performance and Place. Oxford/New York: Berg.

ELLIOTT, P. 1980. The Cross and the Ensign: A Naval History of Malta, 1798-1979, Cambridge, Patrick Stephens.

GOUGH, P. 2002. Invicta Pax monuments, memorials and peace: An analysis of the Canadian Peacekeeping Monument, Ottawa. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 8, 201-223. doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/1352725022000018903

JONES, R. & BIRDSALL-JONES, C. 2003. Native or manufactured?: A comparison of indigenous-industrial heritage conflicts in Perth and Ottawa. Australian-Canadian Studies, 21, 73-106.

OSBORNE, B. S. & OSBORNE, G. B. 2004. The cast(e)ing of heroic landscapes of power: Constructing Canada's pantheon on Parliament Hill. Material History Review, 34-47.

POLLACCO, J. 2003. In the National Interest: Towards a Sustainable Tourism Industry in Malta, Malta, Fondazzjoni Tumas Fenech.

ROBERTS, J. 1998. Nation-building and Monumentalization in the Contemporary Capital: The Case of Ottawa-Hull with Particular Reference to the Peacekeeping Monument and the Canadian Tribute to Human Rights. MA, Department of Geography, Carleton university.

SMITH, P. C. 1970. Pedestal: The Convoy that Saved Malta, London, William Kimber.

SUTTON, R. 2005. Revitalization of Ottawa’s Victoria Island/Chaudiere Industrial District Waterfront. Honours, Department of Geography, Carleton University.

TUNBRIDGE, J. 2003. Type to EBEJER, J.

TUNBRIDGE, J. 2004. Type to ANSON, C.

TUNBRIDGE, J. 2005. Type to SHAW, B. S.

TUNBRIDGE, J. E. 2002. Large heritage waterfronts on small tourist islands: The case of the Royal Naval Dockyard, Bermuda. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 8, 41-51. doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/13527250220119929

TUNBRIDGE, J. E. 2004. The Churchill-Roosevelt bases of 1940: the question of heritage in their adaptive reuse. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 10, 229-251. doi: https://doi.org/10.1080/1352725042000234433

TUNBRIDGE, J. E. & ASHWORTH, G. J. 1996. Dissonant Heritage: The Management of the Past as a Resource in Conflict, Chichester, Wiley.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5130/phrj.v13i0.281