“Indian Ocean News”: Indian Challenges To Australian Racialised Media

Main Article Content

Heather Goodall

Abstract

Two events involving Indians in Australia have grabbed news headlines at different times. One was the 1945 campaign supporting Indonesian Independence in which Indian seamen – known then in Australia as “lascars” – played a high profile role for which they have seldom been acknowledged. The more recent has been the 2009 series of violent attacks on Indian students in Australia, which have aroused major news coverage and public debate in Australia and India. How might “news” media reflect better the potential of both these stories to tell transnational “Indian Ocean news” in which more than one narrative is heard? How, in fact, might they reflect the qualities of the Indian Ocean itself in fostering circulation and dialogue? To contribute to this wider question, this article explores two issues. Firstly, do cultural stereotypes persist over time and, if so, is it because news media re-create and re-circulate them in changing circumstances? Secondly, how does “access” to “making news” come about: whose voices are heard and how are “news” stories identified and told? In the light of what appears to be the simple perpetuation of old stereotypes into the 2009 stories, this paper examines both newspaper and documentary filmic representations of the 1945 campaign. It argues that the outcomes in each case involved selective, rather than wholesale, use of stereotypes. Moreover, each was the result of interaction and often contestation between the participants and the recorders of news – the “sources” and the “producers” – rather than complete dominance by Australian reporters or Western filmmakers over how the stories were told. The paper identifies the more effective of the 1945 strategies used by Indian actors and points to the ways such stories might be read as “Indian Ocean news” which makes visible not only each side of the story but the interactions themselves. This is no longer just a possible future scenario – digital media and internet communication mean that today’s stories are being read and watched almost simultaneously around the world by very different audiences. So working out what “Indian Ocean news” might be is now a matter of urgency.

Article Details

Section
Articles
Author Biography

Heather Goodall, University of Technology, Sydney

Associate Professor, Humanities and social sciences at UTS

References

Ahuja, Ravi (2006) "Mobility and Containment: the voyages of Indian Seamen, c. 1900-1960", International Review of Social History 51 Supplement: 111-41. https://doi.org/10.1017/S002085900600263X

Ahuja, Ravi (2009) "Networks of subordination - networks of the subordinated: the ordered spaces of South Asian maritime labour in the age of imperialism, c.1890-1947", in Ashwini Tambe & Harald Fisher-Tine (eds.) The Limits of British Colonial Control in South Asia, London and New York: Routledge: 13-48.

Allen, Margaret (2008) "A fine type of 'Hindoo' meets 'the Australian type': British Indians in Australia and diverse masculinities", in Desley Deacon, Penny Russell & Angela Woollacott (eds.) Transnational ties: Australian lives in the world, Canberra: ANU ePress: 41-56.

Balachandran, Gopalan (2003) "Circulation through Seafaring: Indian Seamen 1890 – 1945" in Claude Markovits, Jacques Pouchepadass & Sanjay Subrahmanyam (eds.) Society and Circulation: Mobile Peoples and Itinerant Cultures in South Asia, 1750-1950, New Delhi: Permanent Black: 89-130.

Balachandran, Gopalan (2008) "Cultures of Protest in Transnational Contexts: Indian Seamen Abroad, 1885-1945", Trans/forming Cultures eJournal: Cultural Currents of the Indian Ocean 3 (2): 45-75.Broeze, Frank (1981) "The Muscles of Empire - Indian Seamen and the Raj 1919 – 1939", Indian Economic and Social History Review, 1: 43-67.

Carlisle, Wendy (2009) "Holy Cash Cows" Four Corners, Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 27 July 2009: http://www.abc.net.au/4corners/content/2009/s2637255.htm

Cigler, Michael (1986) The Afghans in Australia, Melbourne: Australian Ethnic Heritage Series: 82–83.

Codell, Julie (2006) "Excursive Discursive in Gandhi's Autobiography: Undressing and Redressing the Transnational Self", in D. Amigoni (ed.) Life Writing and Victorian Culture, Aldershot: Ashgate: 166-95.

Cohn, Bernard S. (1996) "Cloth, clothes and colonialism", Chapter 5, in Cohn, Bernard S.: Colonialism and Its Forms of Knowledge. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1996: 106-162.

Cottle, Drew & Keys, Angela (2006) "From Colonial Film Commissioner to Political Pariah: Joris Ivens and the Making of Indonesia Calling" paper presented at the Film and History Conference, Melbourne 2006.

Cottle, Simon (2000) "Rethinking News Access", Journalism Studies 1 (3): 427 – 448. https://doi.org/10.1080/14616700050081768

Daily Mirror, 12 Dec 1945 and 18 Dec 1945 p. 2.

Deshpande, Anirudh (1989) "Sailors and the Crowd: Popular Protest in Karachi, 1946", Indian Economic and Social History Review 26(1): 1-28. https://doi.org/10.1177/001946468902600101

Doust, Janet (2004) "Race and Empire: Setting up Boundaries in Colonial Eastern Australia", Australian Historical Studies 123:152-66. https://doi.org/10.1080/10314610408596279

Ewald, Janet (2000) "Crossers of the Sea: Slaves, Freedmen, and Other Migrants in the Northwestern Indian Ocean, c. 1750 – 1914", American Historical Review 105(1): 1-42. https://doi.org/10.2307/2652435

Goodall, Heather (2008) "Port Politics, Race and Change: Indian Seamen, Australian Unions and Indonesian Independence, 1945 -1947", Labour History 94: 43-68. https://doi.org/10.2307/27516270

Goodall, Heather (2009) "Shared Hopes, New Worlds: Indians, Australians, and Indonesians in the Boycott of Dutch Shipping, 1945–1949", in Shanti Moorthy & Ashraf Jamal (eds.) Indian Ocean Studies: Cultural, Social, and Political Perspectives, London: Routledge: 158-96.

Ivens, Joris (1945) "Indonesia Calling" Heritage Films, copy held in the Australian Film, Television and Sound Archives, Canberra.

Jakubowicz, Andrew, H.Goodall, J.Martin, T.Mitchell, L.Randall and K.Seneviratne (1994): Racism, Ethnicity and the Media, Sydney: Allen and Unwin.

Lingard, Jan (2008) Refugees and Rebels: Indonesian Exiles in Wartime Austalia, Melbourne: Australian Scholarly Publishing.

Lockwood, Rupert (1982) Black Armada: Australia and the struggle for Indonesian independence 1942-49, Sydney: Hale and Iremonger.

Mastro, Dana (2009) "Effects of Racial and Ethnic Stereotyping", in Jennings Bryant & Mary Beth Oliver Media Effects: Advances in Theory and Research, New York and London: Routledge, 3rd ed.: 325-341.

Noel Butlin Archives of Business and Labour, Australian National University Archives, series E177, 1945-1949.

Palfreeman, A. (1967) The Administration of the White Australia Policy, Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.

Palmer, Jerry (2004) "Source Strategies and Media Audiences", Journal of Political Marketing 3 (4): 57 - 77. https://doi.org/10.1300/J199v03n04_03

Rajdowski, Pamela (1987) In the Tracks of the Camelmen, Sydney: Angus and Robertson.

Stevens, Christine (1989) Tin Mosques and Ghantowns: A History of Afghan Cameldrivers in Australia, Melbourne: Oxford University Press.

Sydney Morning Herald, 13 Dec 1945 and 19 Dec 1945.

Sydney Sun, 18 Dec 1945.

The Age, 29 May 2009. http://www.theage.com.au/national/five-teens-charged-overseparate-attacks-on-indian-students-20090529-bptj.html

Tribune, 12 October 1945; 6 November 1945, 9 November 1945, 23 November 1945.

Yarwood, A.T. (1967) Asian Migration to Australia, Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.