Risk Identification and Assessment in PPP Infrastructure Projects using Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process and Life-Cycle Methodology

Jie Li
Patrick Zou


To fulfil the increasing demands of the public,Public Private Partnership (PPP) has beenincreasingly used to procure infrastructureprojects, such as motor ways, bridges, tunnelsand railways. However, the risks involved inPPP projects are unique and dynamic due tolarge amount of investment and longconcession period. This paper aims to developa risk identification framework from theperspectives of project life cycle, and anassessment framework for risks associatedwith PPP project using fuzzy analyticalhierarchy process (AHP). First the paperreviews the current literature to identifycommon risks in PPP infrastructure projectsand classification methods used. The risksidentified from the literature were classifiedusing project life cycle perspectives. Followingthat, the paper presents the advantages offuzzy AHP. Furthermore, the paper provides aframework for assessment of risks in PPPprojects followed by an illustrative examplewhere the data was obtained from surveyquestionnaires. The paper concludes that risksassociated in PPP infrastructure projects areunique and therefore it is beneficial to classifythem from project life cycle perspectives, andthe proposed fuzzy AHP method is suitable forthe assessment of these risks.

Full Text:



Akintoye A., Craig T & Eamon F, (1998), Risk analysis and management of Private Finance Initiative projects, Engineering, construction and Management 5/1, 9-21.

Al-Bahar J. F. (1989), Risk Management in Construction Projects: a systematic Analytical Approach for Contractors. PhD Thesis, University of California, Berkeley, pp 6-27

Asenova D., Beck M, (2003), A financial perspective on risk management in public-private partnership, PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS edited by Akintoye et al, Blackwell Science

AS/NZS 4360 (2004), Australia/New Zealand standard on risk management, Standards Australia and Standards New Zealand.

Australian Government Department of Finance and Administration (2005), Public Private Partnerships Guidelines: Commonwealth Policy Principles for the Use of Private Financing Risk Management (Finance Management Guidance No. 18), May 2005, Commonwealth Australia, 56 pp.

Batley R. (1996), Public-Private relationships and performance in service provision. Urban Studies, 33(4-5), 723-751

Briefing, 2005. Government Guidelines for PPPs Lunched", The Building Economist, June, pp. 2-5."

Buckley, J. J. (1985). Fuzzy, Hierarchical Analysis." Fuzzy Sets and Systems 17, 233-247." http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0165-0114(85)90090-9

Brent A. C., Rogers E.C. D., Ramabitsa-Siimane S. M. T. and Rohwer B. M. (2007), Application of the analytical hierarchy process to establish health care waste management systems that minimise infection risks in developing countries", European Journal of Operational Research, 181: 403-424." http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2006.06.015

Cartlidge, D. (2006), Public Private Partnerships in Construction", Taylor & Francis, London."

Cheng, X. H. (2005). A research based on fuzzy AHP for multi-criteria supplier selection in supply chain." master degree thesis of Taiwan National Science and Technology University"

Cheng, C.H., Yang, K.L., & Wang, C.L., (1999) 'Evaluation attack helicopters by AHP based on linguistic variable weights', European Journal of Operational Research, 116:423-435. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0377-2217(98)00156-8

Darvish H., Zou P.X.W. Loosemore M. and Zhang GM. (2006) Risk management, balance of interest and value for money for PPP projects: literature review and case studies, Proceeding of CRIOCM2006 International research symposium on Advancement of construction management and real estate, 3 â 5 Nov, 2006, Beijing China, pp 546~557

Deng, H. P. (1999). Multicriteria analysis with fuzzy pairwise comparison." International Journal of Approximate Reasoning 21, 215231." http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0888-613X(99)00025-0

Dey K. P. and Ogunlana O. S. (2004), Selection and application of risk management tools and techniques for build-operate-transfer projects, Industrial Management & Data System, 104, 4. 2004. pp. 334-346

Ezekiel and Alasdair (2003), A construction perspective on risk management in public-private partnership, the 5th chapter of Public Private Partnership, Blackwell Science

Flanagan, R. and Norman, G. (1993). Risk management and construction." Blackwell Science"

Fischer K, Jungbecker A, Alfen W. H. (2006), The emergence of PPP Task Forces and their influence on project delivery in Germany, International Journal of Project Management 24 539â547

Gidman P., Blore I., Lorentzen J. & Schuttenbelt P. (1998), Public-Private Partnership in Urban Infrastructure Services. UMP Working Paper Series 4, Nairobi: UNDP/Habitat/Word Bank. pp. 12-36, http://www.ndp.org/pppue/.

Grimsey, D. and Lewis, M.K., (2002) 'Evaluating the risks of public private partnerships for infrastructure projects', International Journal of Project Management, 20:107-118. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0263-7863(00)00040-5

Ho, W., (2007) 'Integrated analytical hierarchy process and its applications â A literature review', European Journal of Operational Research, doi:10.1016/j.ejor.2007.01.004. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2007.01.004

Kang, H.Y., and Lee, A.H.I., (2007) 'Priority mix planning for semiconductor fabrication by fuzzy ranking', Expert Systems with Applications, 32:560-470. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.eswa.2006.01.035

Kim K. H. (1997), Improving local government finance in a changing environment. Habitat International, 21(1), 17-28

Lemos T., Eaton D., Betts M, Almeida L T (2004), Risk management in the Lusoponte concession-a case study of the two bridges in Lisbon, Portugal, International Journal of Project Management 22 63-73;

Li B., Akintoye A., Edwards P.J., Hardcastle C.(2005) The allocation of risk in PPP/PFI construction projects in the UK, International Journal of Project Management 23) 25-35;

Jones A. G., Pisa A. R., (2000), Public private partnerships for urban land development in Mexico: a victory for hope versus expectation, Habitat International 24 1-18

Morgan, P. (1998). Background paper on capacity development and public private partnerships." Mimeography"

Nigim, K.N., Suryanarayanan, S., Gorur, R. and Farmer, R.G., (2003), 'The application of analytical hierarchy process to analyze the impact of hidden failures in special protection schemes', Electric Power System Research, 67:191-196. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0378-7796(03)00127-5

Payne G. (1999), Public/Private partnerships in land for housing, In G. Payne, Making common ground: public/private partnerships in the provision of land for housing, (pp. 1-16). London: Intermediate Technology Publications

PMBOK (2004), A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge, pp, 111-122, Project Management Institute, PMBOK, USA

Raftery, J. (1994). Risk Analysis in Project Management." London: E & FN Spon"

Reijniers, J.J.A.M., 1994. Organization of Public-Private Partnership Projects: The Timely Prevention of Pitfalls", International Journal of Project Management, 12(3), pp. 137-142."

Saaty, T.L., (1980) The Analytic Hierarchy Process, McGraw-Hill, New York

Saaty, T.L., (1982) Decision Making for Leaders. Lifetime Learning Publications, Belmont, California

Salman, A. F.M, Skibniewski, M. J., Basha, I. (2007). BOT viability model for large-scale infrastructure projects." Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, ASCE / January"

Singh, L. B., Kalidindi, S. N. (2006). Traffic revenue risk management through Annuity Model of PPP road projects in India." International Journal of Project Management, 24, 605-613;"

Spackman, M., (2002). Public-Private Partnerships: Lessons from the British Approach", Economic Systems, Vol. 26, pp. 283-301." http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0939-3625(02)00048-1

UNCHS (1993), Public/private partnership in enabling shelter strategies. UNCHS

Wang L.L. (2006), Such a thorny rose â interview with the famous BOT expert

Professor Wang SQ, Construction Enterprise Management, Jun. (214), pp. 2~4

Wang S.Q. et al, (2000) Evaluation and management of foreign Exchange and revenue risks in China's BOT projects, Construction Management and Economics 18, 197-207;

Wang, Y.M., Luo, Y. and Hua, Z.S., (2007) 'On the extent analysis method for fuzzy AHP and its applications', European Journal of Operational Research, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2007.01.050

Zhang, Z. Y. (1991). The Introduction of Fuzzy Mathematics and its application in Construction Management (in Chinese). Bei Jing: China Architecture & Building Press

Zhang, X., 2005. Critical Success Factors for Public-Private Partnerships in Infrastructure Development", Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 131(1), pp. 314."

Zhang, G.M. and Zou, P. X. W. (2007). Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process Risk Assessment Approach for Joint Venture Construction Projects in China." Journal of Construction and Management, ASCE, October"

Zou. P.X.W., Zhang, G.M. and Wang, J.Y., (2006) 'Identifying Key Risks in Construction Projects: Life Cycle and Stakeholder Perspectives', in proceedings of PRRES Conference, The University of Auckland Business School, New Zealand, 22-25 January, <http://www.prres.net/index.htm?http:/ /www.prres.net/proceedings/2006p proceedings. asp> (22 April, 2007)

Zou. P.X.W., Zhang, G.M. and Wang, J.Y., (2007) 'Understanding the key risks in construction projects in China', International Journal of Project Management 25 (2007) 601â614. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2007.03.001


DOI: https://doi.org/10.5130/AJCEB.v8i1.2996

Share this article: