From Disparity to Harmonisation of Construction Industry Payment Legislation in Australia: A Proposal for a Dual Process of Adjudication based upon Size of Progress Payment Claim
Since the introduction of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act into New South Wales in 1999, construction industry payment legislation has progressively been enacted on a jurisdiction-by-jurisdiction basis throughout Australia. Of the eight Australian Acts, two distinct legislative models can be discerned – what have been termed the ‘East Coast’ and ‘West Coast’ models. This article compares the two models with respect to their payment systems and adjudication schemes, procedural justice afforded, incursion upon freedom of contract, uptake rates and efficiency. From this comparison, the strengths and weaknesses of the two models are identified. Finally, a dual process of adjudication based on progress payment claim size is proposed for a harmonised model, developed from previous proposals put forward by other authors, which aims to combine the strengths of the two existing models.
Allred, K. G. (2005) Relationship Dynamics in Disputes, in The Handbook of Dispute Resolution, eds M.L. Moffitt, and R.C. Bordone, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, 83-98"
Aronson, M., Dyer, B. and Groves, M. (2004) Judicial Review of Administrative Action, 3rd edition, Thomson Lawbook Co., Sydney, NSW
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2009) 5220.0 - Australian National Accounts: State Accounts, 2008-09 (Reissue), ABS website, viewed 20 November 2010, http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/Latestproducts/5220.0Main%20Features22008-09%20(Reissue)?opendocument & tabname=Summary & prodno=5220.0 & issue=2008-09%20(Reissue) & num= & view=
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2010) 3101.0 - Australian Demographic Statistics, September Quarter 2010, ABS website, viewed 7 June 2011, <http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/3101.0>
Bailey, I. (2009) Harmonisation or Reform of Legislation: Construction Industry and Dispute Resolution (Paper delivered at Construction Law Seminar, Melbourne Law School, 10 November 2009)"
Bell, M. and Vella, D. (2010) From motley patchwork to security blanket: The challenge of national uniformity in Australian security of payment legislation", 84 Australian Law Journal 565"
Brand, M.C. and Davenport, P. (2010) A proposal for a Dual Scheme of statutory adjudication for the building and construction industry in Australia" Proceedings of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors COBRA Conference, Paris"
Brand, M.C. and Uher, T. (2010) Follow-up empirical study of the performance of the New South Wales construction industry security of payment legislation, International Journal of Law in the Built Environment, 2 (1), 7-25"
Building and Construction Industry Payments Agency (2009) BCIPA Report Month - June 2009, Building and Construction Industry Payments Agency (Queensland Government) website, viewed 24 Nov 2010, <http://www.bcipa.qld.gov.au/SiteCollectionDocuments/Fact%20Sheets/OverallStatistics June2009.pdf>
Building and Construction Industry Payments Agency (2010) BCIPA Report Month - June 2010, Building and Construction Industry Payments Agency (Queensland Government) website, viewed 24 Nov 2010, http://www.bcipa.qld.gov.au/SiteCollectionDocuments/Fact%20Sheets/Overall%20 Statistics%202010/Overall%20Statistics%20-%20June%202010.pdf
Building and Construction Payments Agency (2011) BCIPA Report Month â May 2011, Building and Construction Industry Payments Agency (Queensland Government) website, viewed 6 June 2011, <http://www.bcipa.qld.gov.au/SiteCollectionDocuments/
Building Services Authority (Qld) (2010) Building and Construction Industry Payments Act 2004 â Discussion Paper, Building Services Authority website, viewed 2 Nov 2010, <http://www.bsa.qld.gov.au/SiteCollectionDocuments/BCIPA/Publications/Approved%20Final%20Discussion%20Paper.pdf>
Coggins, J., Fenwick Elliott, R., and Bell, M. (2010) Towards Harmonisation of Construction Industry Payment Legislation: A Consideration of the Success Afforded by the East and West Coast Models in Australia, Australasian Journal of Construction Economics and Building, 10 (3), 14-35"
Cole, T.R.H. (2003) Final Report of the Royal Commission into the Building and Construction Industry, Commonwealth of Australia, February 2003"
Construction Contracts Registrar (WA) (2009) 2008/09 Report of the Construction Contracts Registrar, Building Commission (WA Government) website, viewed 24 Nov 2010, <http://www.buildingcommission.wa.gov.au/bid/Annual_Reports_BID.aspx
Davenport, P. (2007) A Proposal for a Dual Process of Adjudication, Australian Construction Law Newsletter, Issue #115, University of Technology Sydney"
Davenport, P. (2010) Harmonisation of Chalk and Cheese, Society of Construction Law Australia website, viewed 18 Nov 2010, <http://www.scl.org.au/assets/Papers/HarmonisationofChalkand-Cheese.pdf>
Department of Services, Technology & Administration (NSW) (2010) Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 & Contractors Debts Act 1997 Discussion Paper, Department of Services, Technology & Administration website, viewed 3 Nov 2010, <http://www.services.nsw.gov.au/updates/security-payment-construction-industry-discussion-paper>
Duncan Wallace, I N (1999) HGCRA Adjudication: Swarms of Wannabes?, 15 (1), Construction Law Journal 20"
Fenwick Elliott, R (2010) Comments on Harmonisation of Chalk and Cheese, Society of Construction Law Australia website, viewed 18 Nov 2010, <http://www.scl.org.au/assets/Papers/CommentsonHarmonisationofChalk-andCheese-RobertFenwickElliott-July2010.pdf>
Folger, R. (1977) Distributive and procedural justice: Combined impact of voice" and improvement on experienced inequity", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 35, 108-119"
Greenberg, J. (1987) Reactions to procedural injustice in payment distributions: Do the ends justify the means, Journal of Applied Psychology, 72, 340-342"
Iemma, M., Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Bill Second Reading Speech, 29 June 1999, Parliament of NSW Legislative Assembly Hansard Transcript
Kanfer, R., Sawyer, J., Earley, P. C. and Lind, E. A. (1987) Participation in task evaluation procedures: The effects of influential opinion expression and knowledge of evaluative criteria on attitudes and performance, Social Justice Research 1, 235-249"
Latham, M. (1994) Constructing The Team - Final Report of the Government/Industry Review of Procurement and Contractual Arrangements in the UK Construction Industry, HMSO, London
LaTour, S. (1978) Determinants of participant and observer satisfaction with adversary and inquisitorial modes of adjudication, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 36, 1531-1545"
Lind, E. A., Kanfer, R. and Earley, P.C. (1990) Voice, Control, and Procedural Justice: Instrumental and Noninstrumental Concerns in Fairness Judgments, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 59 (5), 952-959"
Lind, E. A., Kurtz, S., Musante, L., Walker, L., and Thibaut, J. W. (1980) Procedure and outcome effects on reactions to adjudicated resolution of conflicts of interests, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39, 643-653"
Lind, E. A., Lissak, R. I. and Conlon, D. E. (1983) Decision control and process control effects on procedural fairness judgments, Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 13, 338-350"
Lloyd, H (2001) Adjudication, International Construction Law Review, 437"
McDougall, R (2006) Prohibition On Contracting Out Of The Building And Construction Industry Security Of Payment Act 1999 (NSW), NSW Supreme Court website, viewed 3 Nov 2010, <http://www.lawlink.nsw.gov.au/lawlink/Supreme_Court/ll_sc.nsf/pages/SCO_mcdougall270506>
MacTiernan, A.J., Construction Contract Bill Second Reading Speech, 3 March 2004, Parliament of Western Australia Legislative Assembly Hansard Transcript
Stenning & Associates (2006) Security of Payment in the Tasmanian Building and Construction Industry, Final Report for the Minister Administering the Building Act 2000, Hobart, Tasmania
Thibaut, J., and Walker, L. (1975) Procedural Justice: A Psychological Analysis, Hillsdale, New Jersey, L. Erlbaum Associates
Tyler, T. R. (1987) Conditions leading to value expressive effects in judgments of procedural justice: A test of four models, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52, 333-344"
Tyler, T. R., Rasinski, K. and Spodick, N. (1985) The influence of voice on satisfaction with leaders: Exploring the meaning of process control, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 48, 72-81"
Ury, W., Brett, J. M. and Goldberg, S.B. (1988) Getting disputes resolved: designing systems to cut the costs of conflict, San Francisco, Jossey-Bass
Zhang, T. (2009) Why national legislation is required for the effective operation of the security of payment scheme, 25 Building and Construction Law Journal 376"
Share this article:
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.