The Meaning of the Past: The Perception and Appreciation of History Among Dutch Genealogists

Kees Ribbens
Gerben J Westerhof
Cor van Halen

Abstract


Genealogy is a popular hobby in the Netherlands nowadays. This article presents findings from a survey of 192 members of the Dutch Genealogical Society. This research focuses on the meanings genealogists attach to the past and on the emotions and activities connected to this. Dutch genealogists associate past and history with positive matters. They perceive the past as a source of knowledge and as a beneficial contrast to the present. They show a specific interest in the period between 1500 and 1900, the respondent's place of residence and region, his or her family life and the life cycle. Most of the genealogists are looking for those sources of information that reinforce an emotional connectedness to the past. Their appreciation of historical knowledge shows the continuity that they experience between the present and the past. Nevertheless many genealogists clearly consider the past as different, as a contrast to the present. Judging by their own definitions of terms, genealogists have more interest for 'past' in the sense of what is close by and small-scale, and therefore almost directly accessible, than for 'history' in the sense of the authorized knowledge from the dominant historical canon. Genealogists are a diverse group. Particularly the level of education and the connectedness with the region and place of residence influence the way in which history is perceived. Gender seems to play only a limited role here. Genealogists with higher levels of education have a broader interest, particularly with respect to larger geographical areas and to topics concerning society at large. Education and a geographical separation with the family past seem to stimulate a stronger development of the traditional notion of historical consciousness in addition to an interest in family history.

Keywords


Genealogists; family history; popular historical culture; attitudes towards the past; perception of history; historical consciousness; survey research (the Netherlands)

Full Text:

PDF

References


ANGVIK, M. & BORRIES, B. V. (eds.) 1997. Youth & history. A comparative European survey on historical consciousness and political attitudes among adolescents, Hamburg.

ASHTON, P. & HAMILTON, P. 2003. At home with the past: Background and initial findings from the national survey. Australian Cultural History, 5-30.

BOUWMAN, W. 1997. Youth and history in Nederland. Het Europese onderzoek naar historisch besef bij jongeren en de resultaten in ons land nader bekeken, s-Hertogenbosch.

DORSMAN, L., JONKER, E. & RIBBENS, K. 2000. Het zoet en het zuur. Geschiedenis in Nederland, Amsterdam.

DRAKE, P. J., 2001. Findings from the Fullerton Genealogy Study. [Online] Available at:

FULKERSON, J. 1995. Climbing the family tree. American Demographics, 17, 42-51.

LAMBERT, R. D. 1995. A study of genealogists and family historians. Families, 34, 223-232.

LAMBERT, R. D. 1995. A study or genealogists and family historians. Families, 34, 73-80.

LAMBERT, R. D. 1995. A study or genealogists and family historians. Families, 34, 149-160.

LAMBERT, R. D. 1996. The family historian and temporal orientations towards the ancestral past. Time and society, 5, 115-143. doi: https://doi.org/10.1177/0961463X96005002001

LAMBERT, R. D. 1996. A study of genealogists and family historians. Families, 35, 11-25.

LAMBERT, R. D. 1996. A study or genealogists and family historians. Families, 35.

MERRIMAN, N. 1991. Beyond the glass case: The past, the heritage and the public in Britain, Leicester.

RIBBENS, K. 2002. Een eigentijds verleden. Alledaagse historische cultuur in Nederland, 1945-2000, Hilversum.

RIBBENS, K., WESTERHOF, G. & HALEN, C. V. 2004. De betekenis van het verleden. De beleving en waardering van geschiedenis bij Nederlandse genealogen. Jaarboek van het Centraal Bureau voor Genealogie, 58.

ROSENZWEIG, R. & THELEN, D. 1998. The presence of the past: Popular uses of history in American life. New York.

RUBIN, D. C., RAHHAL, T. A. & POON, L. W. 1998. Things learned early in adulthood are remembered best. Memory and Cognitio, 26, 3-19. doi: https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03211366

SMITS, F. 2003. “Bonifatius was een homo”, Nederland doet proefwerk geschiedenis, Cijfer: een 4. Historisch Nieuwsblad, 12, 42-46.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5130/phrj.v12i0.205