Institutional Barriers to Developing Community Indicators in New Zealand: A Preliminary Assessment

Ali Memon, Karen Johnston


Abstract

There has been enormous activity in many countries and by international agencies during the last few decades to develop indicators to measure trends in different attributes of the environment, including indicators for community wellbeing and for sustainable development. Identifying appropriate indicators of economic, social, environmental, cultural and democratic progress across local government boundaries, as a basis for a strategy to enhance community governance, and as part of a national system of sustainability indicators, is a challenging task. An important dimension that is implicit rather than explicit in the current literature is the significance of institutional barriers to developing indicators. Informed by recent New Zealand experiences, our objective in this paper is to examine those institutional barriers within the context of achieving the wider objectives of the New Zealand Local Government Act 2002 to strengthen participatory democracy and community governance, and the ‘whole-of-government’ sustainable development paradigm that underpins it. We argue that the significance of undertaking the task of indicator development in a collaborative and participatory as well as technically satisfactory manner should not be under-estimated.

Full Text

PDF

References

Bell, S. and Morse, S., 1999. Sustainability indicators: measuring the immeasurable, Earthscan, London.

Besleme, K and Mullin, M 1997, 'Community indicators and healthy communities', National Civic Review, vol. 86, no. 1, pp. 43-52.

Blair, J and Murphy Greene, C 2006, 'Towards a model community indicator programme: drawing experience from the construction of the San Diego-Tijuana CIP', Journal of Humanities and Social Science, vol.1, no. 1, pp. 1-14.

Borrie, N and Memon, A 2005, Long-term council community plans: a scoping survey of local authorities, The International Global Change Institute, University of Waikato, Hamilton.

Borrie, N, Memon, PA, Ericksen, N and Crawford, J 2005, Planning and governance under the LGA: lessons from the RMA experience, International Global Change Institute, University of Waikato, Hamilton.

Brown-Santirso, Martin 2006, 'Sustainable development and the capital approach: conceptual and practical analysis', Working Paper 12, paper presented to the Economic Commission For Europe Conference Of European Statisticians Joint UNECE/OECD/Eurostat Working Group on Statistics for Sustainable Development Second meeting Oslo, 15-16 November 2006, Submitted by Statistics New Zealand.

Canterbury Region Community Plans Group 2005, Draft indicators for monitoring community outcomes; methodology and process for developing indicators, Christchurch City Council, Christchurch.

Department of Internal Affairs, 2006, Analysis of community outcomes from draft LTCCPs 2006-2016, DIA, Wellington.

Durie, Mason 2006, 'Measuring Māori wellbeing', paper presented at the New Zealand Treasury Guest Lecture Series, 1 August 2006, Wellington.

Durie, Mason, Fitzgerald, Eljon, Kingi, Te Kani, McKinley, Sheridan and Stevenson, Brendan 2002, Māori specific outcomes and indicators, Te Puni Kōkiri The Ministry Of Māori Development, Wellington.

Eckerberg, K and Mineur, E 2003, 'The use of local sustainability indicators -case studies in two Swedish municipalities', Local Environment, vol. 8, no. 6, pp. 591 -614.

Hajer, M J, & Wagenaar, H (eds) 2003, Deliberative policy analysis: understanding governance in network society, Cambridge University Press.

Healey, Patsy 2006, 'Transforming governance: challenges of institutional adaptation and a new politics of space', European Planning Studies, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 299-320.

Healey, P, Cars, G, Madanipour, A & C de Maghalhaes 2002, 'Transfoming governance, institutionalist analysis and institutional capacity', in P Healey, G Cars, A Madanipour & C de Maghalhaes (eds), Urban governance, institutional capacity and social mileux, Ashgate Publishing, Aldershot.

Hoernig, H and Seasons, M 2005, 'Understanding indicators' In Phillips, R (ed), Community indicators measuring systems, Ashgate, New York, pp. 3-31.

Innes, Judith 1997, 'Metropolitan development as a complex system: a new approach to sustainability', Working Paper 699, University of California, Berkeley, CA.

Jefferies, R and Kennedy, N 2005, Draft Māori and indigenous environmental performance outcomes and indicators – literature review, KCSM Consultancy Solutions and International Global Change Institute, University of Waikato, Hamilton.

Johnston, Kirsty and Robyn Reid 2006, Lessons learnt from New Zealand's Environmental Performance Indicators (EPI) programmeme, Unpublished paper, Reporting and Review Group, Ministry for the Environment, Wellington.

Kennedy, N and Jefferies, R 2005, Draft kaupapa Māori framework and literature review of key principles, KCSM Consultancy Solutions and International Global Change Institute, University of Waikato, Hamilton.

Kothari, U 2001, 'Power, knowledge and social control in participatory development', in B Cooke & U Kothari (eds), Participation: the new tyranny?, Zed Books, London.

Leonard, L and Memon, A 2008 forthcoming, Community outcome processes as a forum for community governance, International Global Change Institute, University of Waikato, Hamilton.

Manukau City Council 2006, Tomorrow's Manukau – Manukau Āpōpō, Manukau City Council, Manukau.

Manukau City Council, 2004, The Changing Face of Manukau, Manukau City Council, Manukau.

MARCO 2005, Monitoring and reporting community outcomes. A resource kit for integrated monitoring and reporting, Choosing Futures Waikato, Hamilton.

MARCO 2006, Draft benchmark indicator data report, Choosing Futures Waikato, Hamilton.

Meadows, D H 1998, Indicators and information systems for sustainable development, Sustainability Institute, Hartland Four Corners VT.

Metropolitan Sector Group 2007, Quality of life in twelve of New Zealand's cities 2007, Metropolitan Sector Group.

Ministry for the Environment 2006, Reporting on our environment newsletter, MfE, Wellington.

Ministry for the Environment 1997, The state of New Zealand's environment, MfE, Wellington.

Ministry of Culture and Heritage 2006, Cultural wellbeing and local government report 1: definitions and contexts of cultural wellbeing, MCH, Wellington.

Ministry of Economic Development 2005, Economic development indicators 2005, MED, Wellington.

Ministry of Social Development 2006, Social report 2006 , MSD, Wellington.

Ministry of Social Development 2006a, Social report regional indicators, MSD, Wellington.

Phillips, R (ed) 2005, Community indicators measuring systems, Ashgate, New York.

Rydin, Y & Falleth, E (eds) 2006, Networks and institutions in natural resource management. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK.

Rydin, Y, Holman, N and E Wolff 2003, 'Local sustainability indicators', Local Environment, vol. 8. no. 6, pp. 581-589.

Salvaris, M 2000, Community and social indicators. how citizens can measure progress, Institute for Social Research, Swinburne Institute of Technology, Australia.

Statistics New Zealand 2006, Key projects within the regional team in Statistics New Zealand, SNZ, Wellington.

Statistics New Zealand and Ministry for Culture and Heritage 2006, Cultural indicators for New Zealand, SNZ and MCH, Wellington.

Statistics New Zealand, 2002, Monitoring progress towards a sustainable New Zealand, SNZ, Wellington.

Future Taranaki Facilitation Group 2006, Future Taranaki progress report on community outcomes for Taranaki 2006, Taranaki Regional Council.

Thomas Steven & Ali Memon 2007, 'New Zealand local government at the crossroads? Reflections on the recent local government reforms', Urban Policy and Research, vol. 25, no. 2, June, pp. 1–15.

Victorian Community Indicators Project 2006, Measuring wellbeing, engaging communities, final report, VCIP, Sydney.

Victorian Community Indicators Project 2005, Measuring wellbeing, engaging communities, discussion paper, VCIP, Sydney.

Waring, Marilyn 2006, 'Honouring the experts – participatory data gathering'. key note address to New Zealand Council for Social Services annual conference, Ashburton, October 18 2006.

Waring, M J 1990, Counting for nothing: what men value and what women are worth, Bridget Williams, Wellington.