Municipal Local Economic Development and the Multiplier effect: Piloting a Community Enterprise Identification Method in South Africa and Namibia

Lucienne Heideman


Abstract

Local Economic Development (LED) is a contested concept in southern Africa, and has become synonymous with delivery of generic job-creation projects, often grant-dependent and unsustainable. Municipal LED has followed this pattern in South Africa since 1994, with little lasting success. Each local economy is unique, and has its own problems and opportunities. The ’Plugging the Leaks’ method recognizes that communities themselves know best how money enters and exits their area. By asking people to analyse their local economy as a 'leaky bucket', the method puts control back in the hands of local people, rather than external experts, and allows them to analyse their own local economy to identify gaps and opportunities for enterprise. By better networking and working collectively to improve their local economy, local communities are able to re-circulate cash internally. This circulation of cash is explained as the local multiplier effect in the workshops.

A pilot process of running ‘Plugging the Leaks’ workshops in low income communities in South Africa and Namibia revealed that spending choices in these communities are severely limited in a context where there is no effective welfare state. Therefore, empowerment with this method came from the discovery of collective action and networking, rather than from individual spending choices. Local start-up business tends to be limited to survivalist and copy-cat one-person ventures, and are a last resort when formal employment is absent. In this context collective enterprise offers the necessary empowerment for people to attempt financially sustainable ventures that respond to a gap in the local economy. The pilot project is attempting to show that municipal LED staff can play the role of facilitator for initiating the enterprise-identification process and further mobilise state enterprise support agencies around the locus of LED, without crossing the line between facilitation and implementation of ’projects’.

Full Text

PDF

References

Bond, P. 2002, 'Local Economic Development Debates in South Africa' in Municipal Services Project Occasional Paper Series Number 6, February 2002. International Development Research Centre: Kingston Ontario

Cape Agulhas Local Municipality, 2009. Local Economic Development Strategy. Bredasdorp

Central Bureau of Statistics, 2006 Namibian Household Income and Expenditure Survey 2003/2004. National Planning Commission: Windhoek

Cook, J. 1999, 'Empowering people for sustainable development' in Fitzgerald, P. McLennan, A and Munslow, B. Managing Sustainable Development in South Africa. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Devey, R., Skinner, C. & Valodia, I. 2003 Informal Economy Employment Data in South Africa: A critical analysis. TIPS and DPRU Forum: Johannesburg

Escobar, A 1997, 'The making and unmaking of the Third World though development', in Rahnema, M. and Bawtree, V. (eds) The Post-Development Reader. Zed Books: London

GTZ 2008 (German Technical Cooperation), LED White Paper Namibia. Urbanet Online Library

Hindson, D. and Vicente, V. 2005 Whither LED in South Africa? A Commentary on the Policy Guidelines for Implementing Local Economic Development in South Africa Paper South African Regional Poverty Network: Pretoria

Hoadley, E.M., Atkinson, D., Limpitlaw, D. and Tarr, J. 2005, Arandis Socio-Economic Baseline Study. A report commissioned by The Town Council of Arandis, The Rossing Foundation and Rossing Uranium Ltd. Namibia

Lawrence, F & Hadingham, T, 2008, Decentralisation and the challenge of institutionalizing local economic development: Some practical insights from the South African experience, @local. glob 5. Delnet Programme International Labour Organisation: Turin

Meyer-Stamer, J. 2002, Current challenges for local economic development in South Africa: Experience from Mpumalanga. Report for GTZ (German Technical Cooperation), South Africa Office: Pretoria.

Nelson, N & Wright, S (eds). 1995. Power and Participatory Development Theory and Practice. Intermediate Technology Publications: London

Philips, D. 2000. Implementing the market approach to enterprise support: A comparative analysis of matching grant schemes. World Bank: Washington

Pieterse, E. 1999, A Framework to Link LED to Anti-poverty Strategies. Isandla Institute. Department of Constitutional Development: Pretoria

Pottier, J., Bicker, A., & Sillitoe, P. 2003. Negotiating Local Knowledge: Power and Identity in Development. London: Pluto Press

Provincial Local Economic Development Support Programme, 2005. Municipalities and LED: Consolidated Report on the Eastern Cape. Delegation of the European Commission in South Africa: Pretoria

Republic of Namibia 2008. Regional and Local Economic Development. LED White Paper. Windhoek.

Republic of South Africa 1996. Constitution. Pretoria

Republic of South Africa 1997 White Paper on Local Government. Pretoria

Republic of South Africa 2000 Municipal Systems Act. Pretoria

Rogerson, C.M 2010 'Local Economic Development in South Africa: Strategic Challenges' in Development Southern Africa Vol. 27, No. 4, October 2010. Routledge: Pretoria

Rose, R. 2004 At The Interface Between Theory and Practice - Policy Transfer and Lesson-drawing (Learning From Comparative Public Policy: a Practical Guide) Routledge: London

Sibisi, S, 2009 'Brushing against the grains of history: Making local economic development work in South Africa', In Ngubane, J (Ed.), Local Economic Development. DBSA Working Paper Series No.2: Halfway House Johannesburg

Swinburn G., Goga, S. and Murphy, F. 2006 Local Economic Development: A Primer. Developing and Implementing LED Strategies and Action Plans. The World Bank: Washington

Theewaterskloof Local Municipality, 2009, Local Economic Development Strategy.

Caledon Thina Sinako 2007, Report on Investigation into Institutional Location and Roles of Local Economic Development Agencies (LEDA's). Local Economic Development Support Programme in the Eastern Cape Province. Delegation of the European Commission in South Africa: Pretoria

Walvis Bay Biodiversity Report 2008. Local Action for Biodiversity Project. Vlaeberg

Walvis Bay Local Council 2003. Local Economic Development Strategy 2003 – 2008. Namibia: Walvis Bay

Ward, B and Lewis, J 2002. Plugging the Leaks: Making the most of every pound that enters your local economy. New Economics Foundation: London.