Institutional policy learning and formal federal-urban engagement in Canada

Zachary Spicer


Abstract

Canada has experienced two formal federal ministries dedicated to addressing urban issues. The first, the Ministry of State for Urban Affairs, encountered resistance from provincial governments and its fellow departments. Both worked to undermine it. The second, the Ministry of State for Infrastructure and Communities, was created with a more conciliatory tone towards the provincial governments and its ministerial colleagues. This paper examines the establishment of both ministries and tracks their efforts using a policy learning and lesson-drawing framework, concluding that common institutional actors, such as the Privy Council, were responsible for the Ministry of State for Infrastructure and Communities’ change in tone and approach to multilevel governance. General lessons are drawn about inter-governmental relations and multi-level policy formation in federal systems.

Full Text

PDF

References

Barker, A. 1973. Ottawa Won't Play Banker's Role in Urban Problems, Basford Says." Globe and Mail (national edition), 5 June: 9."

Bennett, Colin J.. and Michael. Howlett. 1991. The Lessons of Learning: Reconciling Theories of Policy Learning and Policy Change." Policy Sciences 25 (3) August: 275-294."

Bovens, Mark and Paul t'Hart. 1996. Understanding Policy Fiascoes. New Brunswick: Transaction Press.

Clark, C. and J. Lewington. 2004. Big Cities Dislike Proposal for Dividing Cash." Globe and Mail (national edition), 29 July: A7."

Etheridge, Lloyd S. 1981. Government Learning: An Overview, " in The Handbook of Political Behaviour, Vol. 2, eds. Samuel L. Long. New York and London: Plenum Press, "

Ethridge, Lloyd S. and James Short. 1983. Thinking About Government Learning, " in Journal Of Management Studies, Vol. 20, No. 1."

Feldman, Lionel D. and Katherine A. Graham. Bargaining for Cities: Municipalities and Intergovernmental Relations: An Assessment. Toronto: Institute for Research on Public Policy, 1979.

Forster, J. 2010. Personal interview with Associate Deputy Minister, Infrastructure Canada, 16 March.

Gertler, Len. 1987. Research Based Urban Policy, " in The Ministry of State for Urban Affairs: A Courageous Experiment in Public Administration, eds. H. Peter Oberlander and Arthur L. Fallick. Vancouver: UBC Press."

Globe and Mail. 1976. Danison Will Contact Provinces on Housing Warranty Programs." Globe and Mail (national edition), 30 January: B3."

Globe and Mail 2002. A Little Something for Canada's Cities." Globe and Mail (national edition), 3 May: A14"

Globe and Mail 2003. Parliamentary Secretaries Will Report to Martin." Globe and Mail (national edition), 13 December: A13."

Globe and Mail 2004. Martin's Cities Agenda Belongs in Major Cities." Globe and Mail (national edition), 20 August: A12."

Hall, Peter. 1989. Conclusion: The Politics of Keynesian Ideas, " in The Political Power of Economic Ideas: Keynesianism Across Nations, eds. Peter A. Hall. Princeton: Princeton University Press."

Hall, Peter. 1993. Policy Paradigms, Social Learning and the State: The Case of Economic Policy Making in Britain, " in Comparative Politics, Vol. 25, No. 3."

Howlett, Michael and M. Ramesh. 2003. Studying Public Policy: Policy Cycles and Policy Subsystems. Toronto: Oxford University Press.

Infrastructure Canada. 2004. Report on Plans and Priorities. Ottawa: Government of Canada.

Infrastructure Canada 2005. Report on Plans and Priorities. Ottawa: Government of Canada.

Infrastructure Canada 2006. Report on Plans and Priorities. Ottawa; Government of Canada.

Juneau, A. 2010. Personal interview with former Deputy Minister, Ministry of State for Infrastructure and Communities, 26 March.

Laroche, Y. 2010. Personal interview with former Assistant Deputy Minister for Cities and Communities, Ministry of State for Infrastructure and Communities, 26 April.

Levy, J. 1994. Learning and Foreign Policy: Sweeping a Conceptual Minefield, " in International Organization 48 (2): 279-312."

Lewington, J. 2002. Ontario Wants Federal Deal Before Altering City Powers." Globe and Mail (national edition), 18 June: A6."

Lewington 2004. Ottawa Ready to Move on 'New Deal' for Cities." Globe and Mail (national edition), 25 February: A14."

Liberal Party of Canada. 2004. Moving Canada Forward: The Paul Martin Plan for Getting Things Done. Ottawa: Liberal Party of Canada.

May, P. 1992. Policy Learning and Failure, " in Journal of Public Policy 12(4): 331-54."

Ministry of State for Urban Affairs. 1972. First Annual Report. Ottawa: Government of Canada.

Ministry of State for Urban Affairs 1973. Rapport Annuel pour L'exercise Financier Termine 31 Mars 1973. Ottawa: Government of Canada.

Ministry of State for Urban Affairs 1974. Annual Report: 1973-74. Ottawa: Government of Canada, 1974.

Ministry of State for Urban Affairs 1975. Annual Report: 1974-75. Ottawa: Government of Canada, 1975.

Ministry of State for Urban Affairs 1976. Annual Report: 1975-76. Ottawa: Government of Canada.

Ministry of State for Urban Affairs 1977. Annual Report: 1976-77. Ottawa: Government of Canada.

Ministry of State for Urban Affairs 1978. Annual Report: 1977-78. Ottawa: Government of Canada.

Newman, D.G. The Golden Hour of Municipal Politics, " in The Ministry of State for Urban Affairs: A Courageous Experiment in Public Administration, eds. H. Peter Oberlander and Arthur L. Fallick. Vancouver: UBC Press, 1987."

Oberlander, H. Peter and Arthur L. Fallick. The Ministry of State for Urban Affairs: A Courageous Experiment in Public Administration. Vancouver: UBC Press, 1987.

Pal, Leslie A. 2006. Beyond Policy Analysis: Public Issue Management in Turbulent Times. Toronto: Thomson Nielson.

Prime Minister's Caucus Task Force on Urban Issues. 2002. Canada's Urban Strategy: A Blueprint for Action. Ottawa: Government of Canada.

Plunkett, T.J. 2004. A Nation of Cities Awaits Paul Martin's 'New Deal' Federal Funds for 'Creatures of the Provinces'." Policy Options, February 2002, 23."

Rose, R. 1988. Comparative Policy Analysis: The Program Approach, " in Comparing Pluralist Democracies: Strains on Legitimacy, eds. Mattei Dogan. Boulder: Westview Press."

Rusk, J. 2003. Godfrey Handed New Cities Post." Globe and Mail (national edition), 12 December: A18."

Sabathier, P. An Advocacy Coalition Framework of Policy Change and the Role of Policy Oriented Learning Therin, " in Policy Sciences 21 1988."

Scoffield, H. 2002a. Ottawa Promises Cities 'New Deal'." Globe and Mail (national edition), 19 February: A9."

Scoffield. 2002b. Urban Funding Dominates Liberal Battles." Globe and Mail (national edition), 15 July: A4."

Stritch, Andrew. 2005. Power Resources, Institutions and Policy Learning: The Origins of Workers' Compensation in Quebec, " in Canadian Journal of Political Science 38 (3) September: 549-579."

Taber, J. 2004. PMO Left Stalwarts Hanging." Globe and Mail (national edition), 21 July: A1."

Watkins, L. 1972. Provinces Will Not Tolerate Encroachment on their Rights in Urban Affairs." Globe and Mail (national edition), 4 August: 3."

Winsor, H. 2002. Urban Problems Prompt an Attack of the Dithers." Globe and Mail (national edition), 2 May: A4."