Stronger communities? Changing prospects for community-led strategic planning in New Zealand

Bruno Brosnan, Christine Cheyne


Abstract

New Zealand’s Local Government Act 2002 ushered in a new phase in local government, a phase that is best characterised by the term ‘empowerment’. Not only were councils empowered to promote social, economic, environmental and cultural well-being, in contrast with previous more prescriptive legislation, but citizens were empowered to engage in community-led strategic planning. In many respects the new statute reflected contemporary international public management trends in which governance is increasingly being conducted via networks of public and private actors. However, with the change of government from a centre-left Labour-led coalition to a centre-right National-led government following the November 2008 general election, it is less certain that local government and communities will continue to experience a strengthening of the pluralisation of governance that has been a feature of the past decade. This article argues that the potential disempowerment of local government, and possible attenuation of community-led strategic planning in New Zealand, comes at a time when the momentum for devolution to local government and other communities is increasing elsewhere.

Full Text

PDF

References

ACT Party (2009). Kiwis could learn from British welfare reform plan. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Atkinson, N. (2003). Adventures in democracy: A history of the Vote in New Zealand. New Zealand: University of Otago Press.

AUT University (2008). Local government newsletter. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Beatson, D. (2009). Super-City: the shape of things to come. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Berger, G. (2003). Reflections on governance. Power relations and policy making in regional sustainable development, Planning Theory and Practice 5(3): 219-234.

Blakely, G. (2010). Governing Ourselves: Citizen Participation and Governance in Barcelona and Manchester. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 34:130-145.

Bush, G. (1990). The Historic Reorganization of Local Government. In M. Holland and J. Bostin (Ed.)in The fourth labour government: Politics and policy in New Zealand (2nd Ed), New Zealand: Oxford University Press.

Bush, G.W.A. (1980). Local Government and Politics in New Zealand. Australia: George Allen & Unwin.

Business New Zealand (2001). Submission by Business New Zealand to the Department of Internal Affairs on the Consultation Document Reviewing the Local Government Act 1974. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Campbell, H., Marshall, R. (2000). Public involvement and planning: looking beyond the one to the many. International Planning Studies. 5(3):321-344.

Chess, C. (2000). Evaluating environmental public participation: methodological questions. Journal of Enviornmental Planning and Management. 43(6):769-784.

Cheyne, C. (2002). Central government and its role in community planning. In M. Thomson-Fawcett & C. Freeman (Eds.) Living together: towards inclusive communities. Dunedin: Otago University Press.

Cheyne, C. (2006). Public involvement in local government in New Zealand: a historical account. In J. Drage (Ed.) Empowering communities? representation and participation in New Zealand's local government. Wellington: Victoria University Press.

Chhotray, V., Stoker, G. (2010), Governance Theory and Practice. A Cross Disciplinary Approach. Houndmills, Palgrave Macmillan.

Controller and Auditor-General (2005). Local government: results of the 2005/06 audits. Retrieved on 1 April 2009 .

Controller and Auditor-General (2006a). Matters Arising from the 2006-2016 Long-term Council Community Plans. Parliamentary Paper. Retrieved on 1 April 2009 .

Controller and Auditor-General (2006b). Local Government: Results of the 2006/07 Audits. Retrieved on 1 April 2009 .

Controller and Auditor-General (2009). Reporting on effects of activites in the annual report. Retrieved on 1 April 2009 .

Controller and Auditor-General (2010). Local government: examples of better practice in setting local authorities' performance measures, Retrieved on 17 June 2010 http://www.oag.govt.nz/2010/examples-of-better-practice.

Cousins, M. (2002). Capturing the citizens voice: The use of referenda by New Zealand Local Government. In J. Drage (Ed.) Empowering communities?: Representation and participation in New Zealand's local government. Wellington: Victoria University Press.

Cowell, R. (2004). Community planning: fostering particiaption in the congested state? Local Government Studies. 30(4):497-518.

Dann, C. (1992). Government: Representation and Trust. In D. Novitz and B. Willmott (Ed.) New Zealand in Crisis: A debate about today's critical issues. Wellington: GP Publications Limited.

Department of Internal Affairs (2000). Statement of policy direction for review of Local Government Act 1974. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Department of Internal Affairs (2001). Reviewing the Local Government Act 1974: Consultation Document. Wellington: Department of Internal Affairs.

Department of Internal Affairs (2009). Local government legislation. Retrieved on 19 September 2009 .

Dixon, J.E., Ericksen, N.J., Crawford, J.L., Berke, P. (1997). Planning under a co-operative mandate: new plans for New Zealand. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management. 40(5):603-614.

Eames, D. (2009). Hide to review 'farcical' planning law. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Freeman, C. (2004). Sustainable development from rhetoric to practice? A New Zealand perspective. International Planning Studies. 9(4):307-326.

Geddes, M. (2005). Neoliberalisim and local governance - Cross-national perspectives and speculations. Policy Studies, 26:359-377.

Geddes, M. (2006). Partnership and the Limits to Local Governance in England: Institutionalist Analysis and Neoliberalism. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 30:76-97.

Guaranos-Meza, V. & Geddes, M. (2010). Local Governance and Participation under Neoliberalism: Comparative Perspectives. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 34:115-129.

Gwynn, R. (1998). The denial of democracy. New Zealand: Cosmos Publications.

Hansard (2009). Urgent Debates: Royal Commission of Inquiry into Auckland Governance Government Response. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Head, B.W. (2007). Community engagement: participation on whose terms? Australian Journal of Political Science. 42(3):441-454.

Haus, M., Heinelt, H., Stewart, M. & (eds.) (2004). Urban governance and democracy : leadership and community involvement. New York: Routledge. http://dx.doi.org/10.4324/9780203340950

Hewison, G.J. (2008). The Local Government Act 2002: rationalization or reform? Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Horan, R. (2010). TAFN What's next? Pulse, April, 33-34.

Houston, D., Katavic, M. (2006). Quality in a New Zealand Local Authority: A case study. Total Quality Management and Business Excellence. 17(4):425-438.

Hughes, J. (2007). Lost in translation: communities of practice the journey from academic model to practioner tool. In J. Hughes, N. Jewson, & L. Unwin (Eds). Communities of practice: critical perspectives. New York: Routledge.

Humpage, L. (2009). Submission to the Royal Commission on Auckland Governance. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Kelsey, J. (1993). Rolling back the state: privatisation of power in Aotearoa/New Zealand. Wellington: Bridget Williams Books.

Klijn, E-H. (2008) Governance and Governance Networks in Europe. An assessment of ten years of research on the theme, Public Management Review 10(4): 505-525.

Lane, M.B., Corbett, T. (2005). The tyranny of localism: indigenous participation in community-based environmental management. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning. 7(2):141-159.

Larner, W., Craig, D. (2005). After neoliberalism? Community activism and local partnerships in Aotearoa New Zealand. Antipode. 37(3):402-424.

Lee, S. (2009). Keynote speech to Local Government Human Resources conference. Retrieved on 1 April, 2009, .

Leonard, L., Memon, A. (2008). Community outcome processes as a forum for community governance. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Local Futures (2006). Local Government, Strategy and Communities, Institute of Policy Studies, Victoria University of Wellington.

Local Government Commission (2008). Review of the Local Government Act 2002 and Local Electoral Act 2001. New Zealand: Local Government Commission.

Local Government New Zealand (2003). The Local Government Act 2002: an overview. Retrieved on 25 October 2009 .

Local Government New Zealand (2009). The Local Government Act 2002 and its implications. Retrieved on 19 September 2009 .

Local Government Rates Inquiry (2007). Funding local government. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Martin, S. (2003). Engaging with citizens and other stakeholders. In A.J. Govaird & E. Loffler (Eds). Public Management and Governance. London: Routledge.

McRobie, A. (1985). The electoral system: representing people or electing a dictatorship? In H. Gold (Ed.) New Zealand Politics in Perspective. Auckland: Longman Paul.

Memon, A. (2002). Reinstating the purpose of planning within New Zealand's Resource Management Act. Urban Policy and Research. 20(3):299-308.

Memon, A., Thomas, G. (2006). New Zealand's New Local Government Act: a paradigm for participatory planning or business as usual? Urban Policy and Research. 24(1):135-144.

Miller, C. (2006). New directions in New Zealand's urban planning and research. Urban Policy and Research. 24(3):341-354.

Minister of Local Government (2009). Making Auckland Greater: The Government's decisions on Auckland Governance. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Minister of Local Government, 2010, Decisions for better transparency, accountability and financial management of local government: Local Government Act 2002 Amendment Bill, Wellington: Office of the Minister of Local Government.

Ministry for the Environment (2009a). Implementing your LTCCP. Retrieved on 1 October 2009 .

Ministry for the Environment (2009b). Promoting environmental well-being under the Local Government Act 2002. Retrieved on 1 April, 2009 .

Mulgan, R. (1994). Politics in New Zealand. New Zealand: Auckland University Press.

Myers, D. (1998). Local Government: Time for a New Blueprint. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

National Business Review (2008). Full wrap of parties' election policies. Retrieved 1 June 2009 .

New Zealand Government (2009). Local Government Act 2002. Retrieved on 1 April 2009 .

New Zealand Institute of Economic Research (2009). Auckland's governance reforms: how far will the ripples spread? Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Nyseth, T., Ringholm, T. (2008). Municipal response to local diversity: flexibility in community governance. Local Government Studies. 34(4):471-487.

Nyseth, T. (2010). Network governance in contested urban landscapes, Planning Theory and Practice 9(4): 497-514.

Perkins, H.C., Thorns, D.C. (2001). A decade on: reflections on the Resource Management Act 1991 and the Practice of urban planning in New Zealand. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design. 28:639-654.

Pierre, J. ed. (2000). Debating Governance: Authority, Steering, and Governance. New York: Oxford University Press.

Quality Planning (2009). Relationship between the Local Government Act and the RMA. Retrieved on 1 April 2009 .

Reddel, T. (2002). Beyond participation, hierachies, management and markets: new governance and place policies. Australian Journal of Public Administration. 61(1):50-63.

Rhodes, R.A.W., (1996), The New Governance: Governing without Government, Political Studies, XLIV:. 652--667.

Rhodes, R.A.W. (1997) Understanding governance: policy networks, governance, reflexivity and accountability. Buckingham: Open University Press.

Richards, A. (2002). The Local Government Act Review highlights of the local government Local Government Bill 2009. New Zealand Petroleum Conference Proceedings. February:24-27.

Richardson, M. (2005). Reflections on what was achieved in the Local Government Act 2002. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Richardson, M., Winefield, P. (2007). Review of the Local Government Act 2002: Engagement and decision-making provisions. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Rive, V. (2003). Local Government Act 2002: free at last? NZ Environment. 26:14-27.

Robinson, F., Shaw, K., Davidson, G. (2005). On the side of angels: community involvement in the governance of neighbourhood renewal. Local Economy. 20(1):13-16.

Royal Commission on Auckland Governance (2009). Royal Commission on Auckland Governance: Report. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Scott, C., Reid, M., Yeabsley, J., Zollner, E. (2004). Local government's role in strategic policy and planning. Retrieved on 1 June 2009 .

Slack, K. (2004). Collaboration with the communty to widen participation: partners whitout power or absent friends. Higher Education Quarterly. 58(2/3):136-150.

Smith, M., Mathur, N., Skelcher, C. (2006). Corporate governance in a collaborative enviornment: what happens when government, busienss and civil society work together. Corporate Governance. 14(3):159-171. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8683.2006.00496.x

Society of Local Government Managers (2009a). Piecing it together. Retrieved on 1 October 2009 .

Society of Local Government Managers (2009b). Funding and financial policies. Retrieved on 19 September 2009 .

Sterling, R. 2005. Promoting democratic governance through partnerships? In: Newman, J. (ed.) Remaking governance. People, politics and the public sphere. Bristol: The Policy Press.

Stoker, G. 1998. Governance as theory: five propositions. International Social Science Journal.50:17-28. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/1468-2451.00106

Tenbensel, T. 2005. Multiple modes of governance: Disentangling the alternatives to hierarchies and markets. Public Management Review. 7:267-288. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14719030500091566

Taylor, M. (2006). Communities in partnership: developing a strategic voice. Social Policy & Society. 5(2):269-279.

Thomas, S., Memon, A. (2005). Reinventing local government in New Zealand? A critical reflection of the Local Government Act 2002. Retrieved 1 June 2009 .

Uitermark, J., Duyvendak, J.W. (2008). Citizen participation in a mediated age: neighbourhood governance in the Netherlands. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research. 32(1):114-134.

Wallis, J., Dollery, B. (2002). Local government capacity and social capital. Retrieved on 1 April 2009 .

Wholey, J.S., Hatray, H.P. (1992). The case for performance monitoring. Public Administration Review. 52(6):604-610.

Wilson, V., Salter, J. (2003). A guide to the Local Government Act 2002. North Shore City. Thomson/DSL Publishing.

Waiheke Island Sustainable Development Group (2007). Sustainability as a community and governance issue: Waiheke Island and the Hauraki Gulf- a case study. Retrieved on 1 April 2009 .

Wood, G.A. (1988). Governing New Zealand. Auckland: Longman Paul.

Wood, G.A., Rudd, C. (1996). The politics and government of New Zealand: robust, innovative and challenged. Dunedin: University of Otago Press.