Defining a Canadian approach to municipal consolidation in major city-regions

Jim Lightbody


Where there is a central government with an exclusive mandate over municipalities, along with a state executive structure using the Westminster model, then the consolidation of squabbling municipalities within metropolitan boundaries becomes a distinct possibility

A general model of municipal restructuring for the Canadian metropolis is more widespread than the superficially unique circumstances of each case might suggest. The thinking here is informed by Clarence Stone’s urban regime model, which helps to clarify what influences constituted the political tipping point for central government action. The paper focuses primarily on the Toronto and Montreal city-regional municipal consolidations at the end of the last century.

It is argued that the decisive element in setting the stage for significant change lay in the pervasive influence of corporate Canada in generally shaping provincial political discourse. What has not previously been of much interest for investigators is the matter of direct consequences for the low politics of city-regional governance. As will be seen, they were both tangible and considerable.

Full Text:



Bollens, J.C. Schmandt, H.J. 1982, The Metropolis: Its People, Politics, and Economic Life, 4th edition, Harper and Row, New York.

Borins, Mr. Justice J. 1997, In the Ontario Court of Justice Judgment re: Challenge to the City of Toronto Act 1997 c. 2, S.O, Toronto.

Brownstone, Meyer, Plunkett, T.J. 1983, Metropolitan Winnipeg: Politics and Reform of Local Government, University of California Press, Berkeley.

Deputy Prime Minister, UK 1997, New Leadership for London: The Government's Proposals for a Greater London Authority, July 1997, HMSO, London.

Dowding, Keith 1994, 'Tiebout: A Survey of the Empirical Literature', Urban Studies, XXXI, 767-797.

Frisken, Frances 2007, The Public Metropolis: The Political Dynamics of Urban Expansion in the Toronto Region, 1924-2003, Canadian Scholars' Press, Inc, Toronto.

Frisken, Frances 1993, 'Planning and Servicing the Greater Toronto Area: The Interplay of Provincial and Municipal Interests', in Rothblatt, Donald M., Sancton, Andrew, eds. Metropolitan Governance: American/Canadian Intergovernmental Perspectives: Institute of Governmental Studies, University of California, Berkeley, pp. 153-204.

Garber, Judith A., Imbroscio, David L. 1996, 'The Myth of the North American City Reconsidered: Local Constitutional Regimes in Canada and the United States', Urban Affairs Review, 31, 5 (May), pp. 595-624.

Graham, Katherine, Phillips, Susan with Allan M. Maslove 1998, Urban Governance in Canada: Representation, Resources, and Restructuring, Harcourt, Brace, Toronto.

Ibbitson, John 1999, 'New city of Ottawa a capital idea', Globe and Mail, 25 September.

Kaplan, Harold 1982, Reform, Planning, and City Politics: Montreal, Winnipeg, Toronto, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

Kaplan, Harold 1967, Urban Political Systems: A Functional Analysis of Metro Toronto, Columbia University Press, New York.

Leo, Christopher, Brown, Wilson 2000, 'Slow Growth and Urban Development Policy', Journal of Urban Affairs, 22, 2 (Spring), pp. 190-213.

Lightbody, James 2006, City Politics, Canada, Broadview Press, Toronto.

Lightbody, James 1999, 'Canada's Seraglio Cities: Political Barriers to Regional Government', Canadian Journal of Sociology, 24, 2 (Summer), pp. 175-191.

Lightbody, James 1998, 'Council Multiplicity and the Cost of Governance in Canadian Metropolitan Areas, ' Canadian Journal of Urban Research, 7, 1 (June), pp. 27-46.

Lightbody, James 1997, 'A New Perspective on Clothing the Emperor: Canadian Metropolitan Form, Function and Frontiers, ' Canadian Public Administration, XXXX, 3 (Fall), pp. 436-456.

Lightbody, James 1978, 'The Reform of a Metropolitan Government: The Case of Winnipeg, 1971, ' Canadian Public Policy, IV, 4 (Autumn), pp. 489-504.

Long, Norton 1968, 'Political Science and the City, ' in Leo F. Schnore, ed. Social Science and the City. New York: Praeger, pp. 243-262.

Manitoba 1971, Legislature Committee on Municipal Affairs, Transcript of Hearings (July).

Osborne, David, Gaebler, Ted 1992, Reinventing Government: How the Entrepreneurial Spirit is Transforming the Public Sector, Penguin, New York.

Sancton, Andrew 1994, Governing Canada's City-Regions: Adapting Form to Function, Institute for Research on Public Policy, Toronto.

Sancton, Andrew 1979, 'The Impact of language differences on metropolitan reform in Montreal, ' Canadian Public Administration, XXII, 2 (Summer), pp. 227-250.

Savitch, H.V., Vogel, Ronald K. 1996, Regional Politics: America in a Post-City Age, Sage, Thousand Oaks.

Smallwood, Frank 1972, 'The Politics of Regional Government, ' in Lionel Feldman and M.D. Goldrick, eds, Politics and Government of Urban Canada, Methuen, Toronto, pp. 333-343.

Stephens, G. Ross, Wikstrom, Nelson 2000, Metropolitan Government and Governance: Theoretical Perspectives, Empirical Analysis, and the Future, Oxford University Press, New York.

Stone, Clarence 1989, Regime Politics: Governing Atlanta, 1946-1988, University Press of Kansas, Lawrence.

Stone, Clarence, Sanders, Heywood, eds. 1987, The Politics of Urban Development, University Press of Kansas, Lawrence.

Taraska, Peter 1976, Report and Recommendations, Committee of Review, City of Winnipeg Act, Queen's Printer, Winnipeg.

Tiebout, Charles M. 1956, 'A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures, ' Journal of Political Economy, 64, 4 (October), pp. 416-24.

Toronto 1999, Building the New City of Toronto Status Report, June []

Trepanier, Marie-Odile 1993, 'Metropolitan Government in the Montreal Area, ' in Rothblatt, Donald N., Sancton, Andrew, eds, Metropolitan Governance: American/Canadian Intergovernmental Perspectives, Institute of Governmental Studies, University of California, Berkeley, pp. 53-110.

Valpy, Michael 1997, 'Local democracy, tossing leaflets from an electronic sleigh, ' Globe and Mail, 16 January.

Vaughan, Colin 1997, 'Ratepayers' groups gear up for Megacity, ' Globe and Mail, 3 February.

Vince, Anne 1997, 'Amalgamations, ' in Brian Dollery, Neil Marshall, eds, Australian Local Government: Reform and Renewal, Macmillan, Melbourne, pp. 151-71.