Effect of the Building Act 2011 on compliance costs in Western Australia

Elizabeth Bazen


Abstract

 The Building Act 2011 commenced in Western Australia on 2 April 2012. It introduced private certification for design and construction compliance, and reduced fees and timeframes for local governments to issue permits. This research project assessed the effect of the Act on the time and cost of building approvals in WA, using an internet-based, self-completion survey to obtain feedback from people on their experience of the new building approvals process.

 

 This research compared the cost of approval for 16 building projects under the new and old approvals processes. The research concluded that the new approvals process appears to be cost-neutral for the building industry as a whole. However, the cost of approval for the 11 building projects studied valued up to $1 million, particularly alterations to existing buildings, is an average of 4.0 times greater under the new approvals process.

Keywords

building; legislation; private certification; post-implementation review;

Full Text

PDF

References

ABC News (2012) Dramatic drop in WA building approvals Australian Broadcasting Corporation viewed 2 May 2013

ACT Planning and Land Authority (2010) Building quality in the ACT: report to the ACT Legislative Assembly Australian Capital Territory Government viewed 12 October 2013

Australian Building Code Board (2011) Building code of Australia 2011 extract from BCA volume 1 part A3 Classification of buildings and structures Department of Commerce viewed 28 September 2013

Australian Institute of Building Surveyors (2011) WA Building Act implementation viewed April 2013

Australian Institute of Building Surveyors (2012) Peak body calls for review of new Building Act in Western Australia viewed 31 December 2012

Brace, I (2008) Questionnaire design: how to plan, structure and write survey material for effective market research 2nd edition Kogan Page, London and Philadelphia

City of Bayswater (2011) Planning and development services & administration and community services agenda 19 September 2011 viewed 29 April 2013

Department of Commerce (2011) The new building approvals system: a guide to the Building Act 2011 in Western Australia draft edition, Government of Western Australia viewed 19 September 2013

Department of Commerce (2012a) Building permit applications - prospective owners Industry bulletin 002/2012 Government of Western Australia viewed 2 May 2013

Department of Commerce (2012b) Variations and amendments to building work Industry bulletin 003/2012 Government of Western Australia viewed 2 May 2013

Department of Commerce (2012c) Building Commission regulations changes Industry bulletin 004/2012 Government of Western Australia viewed 2 May 2013

Department of Commerce (2012d) Further moves to fast-track building approvals Industry bulletin 005/2012 Government of Western Australia viewed 2 May 2013

Department of Commerce (2012e) Advice to permit authorities: SAT decision: [2012] WASAT 156 31 July 2012 Industry bulletin 006/2012 Government of Western Australia viewed 2 May 2013

Department of Commerce (2012f) Building permits now required before work commences Industry bulletin 008/2012 Government of Western Australia viewed 2 May 2013

Department of Commerce (2012g) Building Act amendments Industry bulletin 010/2012 Government of Western Australia viewed 2 May 2013

Department of Commerce (2012h) Occupancy permits for renovation, fitout or other minor work Industry bulletin 015/2012 Government of Western Australia viewed 2 May 2013

Department of Commerce (2012i) Building amendment regulations (no 2) 2012 Industry bulletin 016/2012 Government of Western Australia viewed 2 May 2013

Department of Commerce (2013a) Updated building approval forms Industry bulletin 019/2013 Government of Western Australia viewed 15 October 2013

Department of Commerce (2013b) Building permits for fit outs Industry bulletin 023/2013 Government of Western Australia viewed 15 October 2013.

Department of Commerce (2013c) Extension of Ministerial Order regarding owner signatures Industry bulletin 025/2013 Government of Western Australia viewed 15 October 2013

Department of Commerce (2013d) Post-graduate survey on building approvals Government of Western Australia viewed 18 September 2013.

Department of Housing and Works (2005) A new building act for Western Australia discussion draft Government of Western Australia viewed 3 January 2013.

Department of Local Government and Planning (2003) National competition policy review of the Building Act 1975 Queensland Government viewed 12 October 2013.

Hilmer, FG et al (1993) National competition policy Australian Government Publishing Services, Canberra viewed 19 October 2013

Holbrook, AL, Krosnick, JA and Pfent, A (2008) 'The causes and consequences of response rates in surveys by the news media and government contractor survey research firms' in Lepkowski, JM, Tucker, C, Brick, JM, de Leeuw, E, Japec, L, Lavrakas, PJ et al (eds) Advances in Telephone Survey Methodology John Wiley & Sons Inc. viewed 11 October 2013 http://www.stanford.edu/dept/communication/faculty/krosnick/docs/2007/2007%20TSMII%20chapter%20proof.pdf >

Housing Industry Association (2011) HIA welcomes deferment of Building Act 2011 Housing Industry Association Limited viewed April 2013

Iacomella, L (2012a) Action on delays with occupancy permits Property Council of Australia viewed 31 December 2012

Iacomella, L (2012b) Changes to Building Act in parliament Property Council of Australia viewed 31 December 2012

Lague, M (2012a) Building debacle triggers crisis The West Australian viewed 31 December 2012

Minister for Local Government (2000) What 2000 holds for local government - the Minister's perspective Speech delivered at the WAMA/MT Breakfast Forum Tuesday 15 February 2000 viewed 3 January 2013

National Competition Council (2007) Legislation review and reform Commonwealth of Australia viewed 19 October 2013

O'Brien, S (2011) Building industry revolution for Western Australia Government of Western Australia viewed 14 October 2013

O'Brien, S (2012a) Milestone for building industry Government of Western Australia viewed 31 January 2013

O'Brien, S (2012b) Govt moves to fast-track building applications and approvals Government of Western Australia viewed 31 January 2013.

Parker, G and Wright, S (2012) Building mix-ups put jobs at risk The West Australian viewed 31 December 2012

Productivity Commission (2004) Reform of building regulation research report viewed 3 January 2013

Property Council of Australia (2012) Red-tape reduction for commercial fitouts viewed 19 Sept. 2013

Self, B, Roche, G and Hill, N (2012) Customer satisfaction measurement for ISO 9000:2000 Taylor and Francis

SurveyMonkey (2013) viewed 19 September 2013.

Trenwith, C (2012) Emergency meeting over alarm WA building drop WA Today viewed 3 January 2013

Victorian Auditor General (2011) Compliance with building permits Victorian Government Printer viewed 12 October 2013

Western Australian Government (2009) Committee reports: government response legislative council standing order 337 viewed 31 December 2012.

Building Act 1975 (Queensland) viewed 12 October 2013.

Building Act 1993 (Victoria) viewed 12 October 2013

Building Act 2004 (Australian Capital Territory) viewed 12 October 2013

Building Act 2011 (Western Australia) viewed 31 December 2012

Building Regulations 1989 (Western Australia) viewed 31 December 2012

Building Regulations 2012 (Western Australia) as at 13 March 2012, viewed 31 December 2012

Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1960 (Western Australia) as at 13 March 2012, viewed 31 December 2012

Article Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Metrics powered by PLOS ALM