A Refined Basket of Goods Approach for Comparing Construction Costs between Countries

Rick Best


Abstract

Most comparisons of construction industry performance requirethat construction costs be converted to a common base. Existingmechanisms for such conversions produce unreliable results.A proposed method for producing industry-specifi c conversionfactors was tested using a single building type. A basket ofmaterials and labour was identifi ed and weighted to refl ect the costshare of each item in a completed project. Prices for the basketwere gathered in three cities and simple construction specifi cconversion indices were calculated based on the constructionpurchasing power of each currency. The construction purchasingpower parities (CPPPs) showed marked differences from otheravailable conversion mechanisms such as exchange rates andgeneral purchasing power parities (PPPs) that have been used inprevious international comparison studies. While the study waslimited in scope, and is only the fi rst stage of a longer process, thesubstantial differences in comparative costs based on purchasingpower illustrate the problems inherent in international costcomparisons. For example, comparing Singapore and Sydney,Singapore costs appear to be only 40% of those in Sydney (basedon exchange rates) about two-thirds the cost of Sydney (usinggeneral PPPs) or almost the same (using the preliminary CPPPs).These results illustrate the problems of converting costs fromlocal currencies to a single base currency and suggest that furtherdevelopment is needed to improve the reliability of outcomes.

Full Text

PDF

References

Best, R. (2010) 'Using 'building blocs' for international construction cost comparisons', in de Valence, G. (ed.) Modern construction economics, Spon Press (in press).

Best, R. (2007) 'Currency conversions for construction cost comparisons: purchasing power parities and exchange rates', in proceedings of Construction Management and Economics 25th Anniversary Conference, University of Reading, July 16-18.

Best, R. and Langston, C. (2006a) 'Evaluation of construction contractor performance: a critical analysis of some recent research', Construction Management and Economics, 24(4), 439-445.

Best, R. and Langston, C. (2006b) 'Converting construction costs to a common currency base: an unresolved problem', in proceedings of Construction in the XXIst Century: Local and Global Challenges, Rome, October 18-20.

Blake, N., Croot, J. and Hastings, J. (2004) Measuring the competitiveness of the UK construction industry: volume 2, Experian business strategies, London: Department of Trade and Industry.

BWA (2006) Benchmarking of use of construction (costs) resources in the member states (pilot study), London: Bernard Williams Associates.

Cordell (2003) Cordell commercial and industrial building cost guide, Canberra: Reed Data Services, October.

Cordell (2007) Cordell commercial and industrial building cost guide, Canberra: Reed Data Services, July.

Danish Agency for Trade and Industry (2000) Construction costs in Denmark: a comparison with other countries, Copenhagen: Ministry for Business and Industry.

DLC (2003) An initial test exercise on a basket of goods approach to construction price comparisons, London: Davis Langdon Consultancy.

Dubner, M. and McKenzie, R. (2002) 'Construction industry purchasing power parities: obtaining comparable prices', in proceedings of Conference on the International Comparison Program, Washington, D.C., March 11-14 (available at http://www. worldbank.org/data/icp/documents/dms.doc).

Goodchild, G. and Grif?ths, D. (2004) New Zealand's involvement in the joint OECD-Eurostat Purchasing Power Parities Programme, Statistics New Zealand Information Paper 2004.

Ive, G., Gruneberg, S., Meikle, J and Crosthwaite, D. (2004) Measuring the competitiveness of the UK construction industry: volume 1, London: Department of Trade and Industry.

Langston, C. and de Valence, G. (1999) International cost of construction study: stage 2, evaluation and analysis, Canberra: Department of Industry Science and Resources (available at hyyp://www.isr.gov.au/library/content_library/BC-CoCStage2.pdf).

Langston, C. and Best, R. (2005) 'Using the Big Mac Index for comparing construction costs internationally', in proceedings of QUT Research Week 2005, Queensland University of Technology, July 4-5.

Lynton (1993) The UK construction challenge, London: Lynton PLC.

Meikle, J. (2003) Summary comparison of approaches to international construction price comparisons, London: Davis Langdon Consultancy, unpublished.

OECD (2005) Purchasing power parities and real expenditures: benchmark year 2002, Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.

Page Kirkland (1999) International cost of construction study: stage 1, base cost of construction, Canberra: Department of Industry Science and Resources.

Rawlinsons (2007) Australian construction handbook 2007 (25th Edition) Perth: Rawlhouse Publishing.

Rogoff, K. (1996) 'The purchasing power parity puzzle', Journal of Economic Literature, XXXIV, 647-668.

Schreyer, P. and Koechlin, F. (2002) Purchasing power parities 1999 benchmark results, Paris: OECD Statistics Directorate.

Stapel, S. (2002) 'The Eurostat construction price surveys: history, current methodology and new ways for the future', in proceedings of International Conference on ICP, World Bank, Washington, 11-13 March.

Stapel, S. (2004) 'Challenging the 'snapshot theory' of purchasing power parities: Eurostat's revision of the PPP 1995 to 2000' (available at http://www.ipeer.ca/papers/Stapel, June6, 2004, _ ?nal_04_6_04.pdf).

UBS (2006) Prices and earnings: a comparison of purchasing power parity around the globe (2006 Edition), Zurich: Union Bank of Switzerland.

Vermande, H. and van Mulligen, P-H. (1999) 'Construction costs in The Netherlands in an international context', Construction Management and Economics, 17(3), 269-283. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/014461999371484

Walsh, K. and Sawhney, A. (2002) International comparison of cost for the construction sector: towards a conceptual model for purchasing power parity, report submitted to the World Bank Group, June.

Walsh, K. and Sawhney, A. (2004) International comparison of cost for the construction sector: an implementation framework for the basket of construction components approach, report submitted to the African Development Bank and the World Bank Group, June.

Walsh, K. and Sawhney, A. (2005) International comparison of cost for the construction sector: identi?cation of construction systems and components for the BOCC approach, report submitted to the World Bank Group, November.

World Bank (2007a) Construction sector comparison using the basket of construction components approach: executive summary (available at http://siteresources.worldbank.org/ICPINT/ Resources/Summary_of_BOCC_Approach.doc).

World Bank (2007b) 2005 International Comparison Program preliminary global report compares size of economies (available at http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/NEWS/0, , conte ntMDK:21589281~menuPK:34463~pagePK:34370~piPK:34424~t heSitePK:4607, 00.html).