Construction Tender Subcontract Selection using Case-based Reasoning

Due Luu
Wily Sher


Obtaining competitive quotations from suitably qualified subcontractors at tender tim n significantly increase the chance of w1nmng a construction project. Amidst an increasingly growing trend to subcontracting in Australia, selecting appropriate subcontractors for a construction project can be a daunting task requiring the analysis of complex and dynamic criteria such as past performance, suitable experience, track record of competitive pricing, financial stability and so on. Subcontractor selection is plagued with uncertainty and vagueness and these conditions are difficul_t o represent in generalised sets of rules. DeciSIOns pertaining to the selection of subcontr:act?s tender time are usually based on the mtu1t1onand past experience of construction estimators. Case-based reasoning (CBR) may be an appropriate method of addressing the chal_lenges of selecting subcontractors because CBR 1s able to harness the experiential knowledge of practitioners. This paper reviews the practicality and suitability of a CBR approach for subcontractor tender selection through the development of a prototype CBR procurement advisory system. In this system, subcontractor selection cases are represented by a set of attributes elicited from experienced construction estimators. The results indicate that CBR can enhance the appropriateness of the selection of subcontractors for construction projects.

Full Text:



Aamodt, A. and Plaza, E. (1994). Case based reasoning:foundational issues, methodological variations and system approaches, Artificial Intelligence Communication, No. 7, 39-59.

Barletta, R. (1991). An introduction to case-based reasoning, AI Expert, 43-49.

Brown, S. J. and Lewis, L. M. (1993). A case-based reasoning solution to the problem of redundant resolutions of nonconformances in large-scale manufacturing, Innovative Applications of Artfficiallntelligence 3, eds. R. Smith & C. Scott, AAAI Press, 121-133.

Kolodner, J. L. (1993). Case Based Reasoning, San Mateo, Morgan Kaufmann Publishers, CA.

Schank, R. C., Kass, A., and Riesbeck, C.K. (1994). Inside Case-Based Reasoning, Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, N.J.

Shash, A. A. (1998). Bidding Practices of Subcontractors in Colorado, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management , May/June 1998, 219-225.

Tam, E. (2003).STAT-USA Market Research Reports, U.S. & Foreign Commercial Service and U.S. Department of State, 2003.

Tang, H. {2001).Construct for excellence, report of the construction industry review committee, January 2001. The Printing Department, HKSAR.