Value Management in Practice: An Interview Survey

Therese Daddow, Martin Skitmore


Despite its obvious theoretical benefits, there has been some reservations regarding the practical implementation of Value Management (VM) for construction projects. In particular, these concerns the extra time and costs involved in conducting VM in relation to the actual benefits gained as a consequence of its use. This paper provides the result of an interview survey of the experiences and observations of 17 professionals working in the property and construction industry to establish the extent to which this is an issue. The main conclusion is that the process is working well, with VM being popular among those with experience in its use - which has been extended into the area of consultant selection. However, in contrast with the prescriptive literature, much of the participants' experiences appear to be more concerned with VM's contribution to the identification and management of the risks involved in project delivery than the straight value-for-money aspects. This may be due to the higher levels of uncertainty involved in construction work than in VM's original use in construction.


value management, practice, applied, construction, property, survey

Full Text:



Adam, E 1993, .Value Management: cost reduction strategies for the 1990s., Longman Cheshire Pty Limited, Melbourne, Australia.

Barton, Roy 2002, .Value Management and Complexity in Infrastructure Project Initiation., PhD Thesis, James Cook University, Australia.

Bordass, W 2000, .Cost and value: fact and fiction., Building Research and Information, 28 (5/6) 338-52.

Clark, L 2000, .The Need for a new VM Standard in Australia., Paper presented to the Institute of Value Management Australia Conference, Queensland, Australia.

Covey, S R 1989, The 7 habits of highly effective people, Simon & Schuster, New York, USA.

Daddow, Therese 2002, .A Practical Observation of Value Management., Masters Thesis, Queensland University of Technology, Australia.

Dean, E B 1997, Value Engineering from the perspective of competitive advantage, null

8 Dell.Isola, A J 1982, Value Engineering in the construction industry, 3rd Ed. Van Nostrand Reinhold Company Inc., New York, USA."

Dobrow, P V, Macedo, Manuel C and O.Rourke, Joseph J 1978, Value Management for construction, John Wiley & Sons Inc, Toronto, Canada.

Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council 2001, Group Decision Support for Value Management . null

11 European Commission, 1999, Innovation management . building competitive skills in SMEs, European Communities, Belgium."

Fowler, T. C. (1990). Value analysis in design, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York NY.

Green, S D 2001, Beyond Value Engineering: smart value management for building projects, null

14 Hyuan, C T 1997, .Making Value Engineering as an effective tool for project integration using constructability and partnering concepts., Paper presented to the SAVE International Proceedings -1997 Annual Conference, ed. O James Vogl, Illinois, USA."

Institute of Value Management 2001, Competitiveness through value, null

16 Kinnan, M., Kinnan, M., Martin, S., 2001, But we already do it, and other misunderstandings,

Mantel Jr, SJ and Meredith, JR 1995, Project Management . a managerial approach, John Wiley & Sons Inc., Canada.

Martin, S 2001c, Application of value method procedures in non-engineering processes, null

19 Martin, S 2001d, But we already do it!

Martin, S J 1997, .What.s the difference?. Paper presented to the SAVE International Proceedings -1997 Annual Conference, ed. O James Vogl, Illinois, USA. null

21 Martin, S J 2001a, Constructively measuring value programs effectiveness,

Martin, S J 2001b, Value program and study teams success through cooperative interplay, null

23 McGill University (McGill) 2001, Value Engineering at McGill University,

New South Wales Government 1990, Value Management manual, NSW Government, NSW, Australia.

Office of the Under Secretary of Defense 2001, Earned Value Management, null

26 Queensland Department of Public Works and Housing 1996, Strategic Asset Management . Value Management 7.2, Queensland Government, Australia."

Ritz, G J 1994, Total Construction project Management, McGraw-Hill Inc, USA.

Save International (SAVE) 2001, Benefits of using the value methodology, null

29 Stokes, E 1998, Unit 303 . Project management, APESMA, Deakin University, Victoria, Australia."

Systematic Analytic Methods and Innovations 2001, Value analysis results, null

31 The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) 2000, Quantity Surveying 2000 . The future role of the Chartered Quantity Surveyor, Godfrey Lang Limited, London."

Thiry, M ed. 1997, The Bovis Self Development Program . Executive Module: Value Management, A draft SDP document.

Thompson, J L 1995, .Strategic management: awareness and change., Journal . Operational Research Society, 2nd Edition, vol. 46 no. 11, pp. 1398.

University of Canberra 1995, Competency Standards for the Value Management Facilitator, UC, NSW, Australia.