Peer Assessment for Construction Management and Quantity Surveying Students

Patricia McLaughlin


Students undertaking the Bachelor of ConstructionManagement degree course at RMIT University, Melbourne,qualify for registration with the Australian Institute ofQuantity Surveyors (AIQS) and the Australian Institute ofBuilding (AIB) upon graduation. Over the past decade thedegree course has been constantly upgraded and altered inline with recommendations from professional bodies such asthese and other industry partners. In 1994 the Departmentof Building and Construction Economics re-assesseda range of subjects including the first year technologysubjects. Out of the review a problem-based integratedlearning unit was developed and tested. This unit has nowbeen in place for ten years.Quantity surveying and construction management likemost other professions in the construction industryrequire teamwork and advanced consultation skills. Theseskills may be learnt through experience but there isconsiderable evidence that these skills can be taught in theundergraduate years. Therefore in line with team-basedapproaches used in industry and professional constructionsettings, this year a new assessment model - peerassessment - will be applied to the problem-based learningunit. This paper describes the procedures and processesused to introduce the change and examines the theoreticalbase upon which the model was developed.

Full Text:



Astin, Banta, I., Cross, P., El-Ktiawas, E. and Ewell, P, (1996), Principles of Good Practice for Assessing Student Learning viewed 19 August 2003,

Beaumont-Kings, C. (1994), Ttie Impact of Assessment on Learning, Paper presented at AARE Conference 1994 November, Newcastle, Australia, null

3 Boud, (2001). Implementing Student Self-Assessment, vievi^ed on 18 August 2003,

Brown, Bull and Pendlebury, (1997). Assisting Students to Understand ttie Criteria for Group Assignments UTS, viewed 18 August 2003, iittp://www, imi,, au/Learnteacti/ assess/guides/0112, titm.

Brown, Race and Smitii, (1988). Effective Laboratory Teactiing. Effective Teaching in Higiier Education, 5, 91-114.

Brubacher J. (1977), On the Phiiosophy of Higher Education. Jossey Bass, San Francisco, null

7 Bulman, T. (1998). Peer Assessment between Students In Colleges and Universities. Review of Educational Research 1 68 (3), 249-277."

Candy, P., Crebert, C. and O'Leary, J, (1994). Deveioping Lifeiong Learners through Undergraduate Education. N.B.E.E.T Australian Government Printing Service, Canberra.

Chalmers, D. (1996). Teaching for Learning at University: Theory and Practice. Kegan Paul, London.

Chen, S., Jefferies, M. and Conway, J. (1999). Ethics and Professional Values. In Themes and Variations in PBL (edited by Conway J.). APBLN, Newcastle, Australia, null

11 Chin, R, and Overton, T (2003). Assessing Group Work LTNS Physical Services, viewed 18 August 2003."

Cohen and Simpson, (1999). Peer Leaning and Assessment. Assessment and Evaiuation in Higher Education, 24 (4), 413-426.

Conway, Kember, D Sivan, A, and Wu, M.. (1993). Peer Assessment: an Individual's Contribution to a Group Project. Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education. 18, 45-56.

Crooks, TJ. (1988). The Impact of Classroom Evaluation Practices on Students. Review of Educational Research, 58, 4, ,

15 Dall'Alba, G, and Sandberg, J, (1993), A Competency Based Approach to Education and Training. HERDSA News, 15(1), 2-5."

Gatfield, (1999). Examining Student Satisfaction with Group Projects and Peer Assessment. Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education 31, 365-377, null

17 Gee, J. (1996), The New Work Order. Allen & Unwin, New York."

Gibbs, G. (1992). Improving the Quaiity of Student Learning. Bristol: Technical and Educational Services.

Gipps, C.V. (1994). Beyond Testing. Farmer Press, London.

Goldfinch and Raeside, (1990). Further Developments in Peer Assessment of Projects. Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education. 1925-1934.

Habeshaw, (1989). Teaching Practicals. Preparing to Teach. (edited by Habeshaw) Routledge Paul, London.

Hodgeman, J. (1997). The Development of Peer and Self-assessment Strategies for a Design and Project-based Curriculum, viewed 18 August 2003. http:/ / edu. au/ Articles/dec97/hodgm1 .htm.

Kember and Gow, (1991). A Challenge to the Stereotype Studies. Higher Education 16 (2), 117-128.

Kerr, R, Park, K. and Domazlicky, B. (1995). Peer Grading of Essays in a Principles of Microeconomics Course. Journal of Education for Business 70 (6), 357.

Li, (2001). Some Refinements of Peer Assessment of Group Projects. Assessmenf and Evaluation in Higher Education 26, 5-18.

Lin, R., Liu, E. and Yuan, S. (1991). Complex Performance Based Assessment, Expectation and Validation Criteria. Educational Researcher 20, 15-21.

Linn, (1991).Complex performance Based Assessment Expectation and Validation Criteria. Educational Researcher 20, 15-21.

Maister, D. (1997). True Professionalism, Simon & Schuster. New York.

McGeorge, D. (1996). An Advocacy for the Use of Problem Based Learning in Construction Management Education. AlB Papers 1, 4-9.

McGettigan, J. (1985). Building 1 BLX176 External Notes. Hawkesbury Agricultural College, Australia.

Mellander, K. (1993). The Power of Learning. American Society for Training and Development. New York.

Nightingale, (1994). Achieving Quaiity Learning in Higher Education. London Kogan Paul.

Niles, (1995). A Comparison of Overseas and Australian Students at an Australian University. Internationa! Journal of Interculturat Relations 19 (3), 369-385.

Nilson, L. (2003). Infiproving Student Peer Feedback. College Teaching 51 (1) 34-39.

Outhred, G. (1995). Using Models to Develop Management Skills and Technical Understanding. Paper presented to AUBEA Conference, Sydney July 1995, Australia.

Pond, K., Ulhaq, R. and Wade, W. (1995). Peer Review: A precursor to peer assessment. Innovations in Education and Training Intemational. 32, 314-323.

Pond, K. and Ul-Haq. R. (1997). Learning to Assess Students Using Peer Review. Sfucfies in Educational Evaluation. 23(4), 331-348.

Race, R (2000). 500 Tips on Group Learning. Kogan Page Ltd. London.

Rafig, Y. and Fullerton, H. (1996). Peer Assessment of Group Projects in Engineering. Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education 21, 35-40.

Ramburuth, (1997). Cross Cultural Learning Behaviour in Higher Education: Perceptions versus Practice. Paper presented at seventh LERN Conference on Learning, Melbourne, July 2000.

Sluijsmans, D., Brand-Gruwel, S. and Merrienboer, J. (2003). The Training of Peer Assessment Skills to Promote the Development of Reflection Skills in Teacher Education. Studies in Educational Evaluation 29 (1), 23.

Topping, (1999). Peer Assessment Between Students in College Universities. Review of Educational Research 68, 249-276.

Volet and Renshaw, (1996). A Short Term Longitudinal Investigation of Cross Cultural Differences in Study Approaches. British Journal of Educational Psychology. 64, 301-318.

Williams, L. (1996). Large Classes, Computers and Assessment. Tertiary Education News, University of Queensland. 6 (1), 4.

Winter, (1995). Development of Criteria for Team Work viewed 18 August 2003,