The Nature of Payment Problems in the New Zealand Construction Industry

Thanuja Ramachandra, James Olabode Rotimi


Delay and loss of payment is a serious problem in the construction industry of many countries. These affect the cash flow of contractors which is critical to meeting their financial obligations. Payment defaults by the principal leads to insolvency of contractors and in turn other parts of the project chain. In recognition of some of these problems, most countries have established payment-specific construction industry legislation and other contractual measures to mitigate the problems, but nevertheless the problem persists. In this context, the paper examines the nature of payment problems in the construction industry in New Zealand. It is part of a larger study, that seeks solutions to payment losses in the construction industry.The study uses two approaches; an analysis of liquidators’ reports, and an analysis of court cases involving payment disputes to determine the magnitude of payment problems on construction parties. The findings are presented using simple descriptive and interpretive analyses. The study finds that trade creditors are impacted negatively (payment delays and losses) by the liquidation of property developers, general construction and construction trade companies. 75% of trade creditors are unable to be paid fully by these categories of construction companies after liquidation proceedings. Liquidation proceedings take an average 18 months before they are finalised. The analysis of court cases found that 80% of payment disputes are between principals and contractors; with considerably significant percentage of disputes resulting in outright loss of payments. Only 40% of the cases are successful, in which case claimants are able to fully recover the amount in dispute. Payment losses are more prevalent in liquidation than delays and unlike in legal disputes, there is no security for those losses. The study finds that construction parties use remedies contained in the security of payment provisions within standard conditions of contract, and legislative documents.


Payment loss, Payment disputes, Liquidation,Construction Industry, New Zealand.

Full Text:



Ang, S. S. (2006) Payment issues - The present dilemmas of Malaysian construction industry (Unpublished MSc thesis), Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, Johor Bahru, Malaysia

Banwell, H. and Ministry of Public Building and Works (1964) The placing and management of contracts for building and civil engineering work: report of the committee: HMSO, London

Barry, S. (2010) 25 firms follow builder into liquidation, Retrieved 17 Feb 2010 from

Brand, M. C., and Uher, T. E. (2008) 'Review of the performance of security of payment legislation in New South Wales', Paper presented at the RICS Construction and building research conference COBRA, 4-5 September, Dublin Institute of Technology, Ireland

Cheng, T., Soo, G., Kumaraswamy, M., and Jin, W. (2009) 'Security of Payment for Hong Kong Construction Industry â Workable alternatives and suggestions', Building Journal Hong Kong China, 60-77

Conlin, J.T., Langford, A.D. and Kennedy, P. (1996) 'The Relationship between Construction Procurement Strategies and Construction Contract Disputes', In Taylor, R.G. (ed.) Proceedings of CIB W92 Symposium: North Meets South: Developing Ideas, University of Natal, South Africa

Construction Contracts Act 2002, no. 46, The Parliament of New Zealand

Davenport, P. (2005) 'Security of payment - the pendulum has swung too far', Australian Construction Law, 101 (March/April), 36-40

Degerholm, P. (2001) 'Construction Contracts Bill 2001', Fortune Manning, July (54)

Degerholm, P. (2003) Managing Contractors' Cashflow, Auckland: Rawlinsons Media Limited

Egan, J. (1998) Rethinking Construction: The Report of the Construction Task Force DETR, London

Euginie, L. (2006) 'Curing the Ills of Non-Payment in the Construction Industry â the Singapore Experience', 8th Surveyors' Congress, Kuala Lumpur: ISM

Gibson, A. (2004, 18 November) Win for builder in court, New Zealand Herald, Retrieved from & objectid=3611310

Gibson, A. (2009, 22 April) Fletcher wins judgement in Melview case, New Zealand Herald, Retrieved from

Heath, B.C., Hills, B. and Berry, M. (1994) 'The nature and origin of conflict within the construction process', in Proceedings of CIB TG15 Meeting in Kentucky, USA, ed. Fenn, P. CIB Publication 171

Johnston S (1999) Debts and Interest in the Construction Industry: A guide to the late payment of commercial debts (interest) Act 1998, Thomas Telford Limited, London

Kennedy, P. (2005) 'Statistics and trends in statutory adjudication in the UK since 1998', Paper presented at the meeting of the International forum on construction industry payment Act and Adjudication, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 13-14 September

Khosrowshahi, R. (2000) 'A radical approach to risk in project financial management', Proceedings of the 16th Annual ARCOM conference, Glasgow Caledonian University, September 6-8, 547-556

Land Transfer Act 1952 No 52 (as at 01 August 2008), Public Act 1952, s 136-137

Latham, M. (1994) Constructing the team: final report of the government/industry review of procurement and contractual arrangements in the UK construction industry: HMSO: London

NZS 3910:2003 Conditions of Contract for Building and Civil Engineering Construction, Standard New Zealand, Wellington: Standard Council

NZS 3915:2005Conditions of Contract for Building and Civil Engineering Construction, Standard New Zealand, Wellington: Standard Council

Odeyinka, H. A. and Kaka, A. (2005) 'An evaluation of contractors' satisfaction with payment terms influencing construction cash flow', Financial Management of Property and Construction, 10 (3), 171-180,

Odeyinka, H.A., Kaka A. and Morledge, R. (2003) 'An evaluation of construction cash flow management approaches in contracting organizations', In Greenwood, D. (ed.) Proceedings of 19th Annual ARCOM conference, University of Brighton, September 3-5, 33-41

Office of Government Commerce. (2007) Guide to best 'Fair Payment' practices, Retrieved 15 January 2010, from

Peer, S. (1982) 'Application of cash flow forecasting models', Journal of the Construction Division ASCE, 108, 226-232

Reilly, J. (2008) Top luxury developer forced into liquidation, Retrieved 3 June 2010, from

Singh, S. and Lakanathan, G. (1992) 'Computer-based cash flow model', In Proceedings of the 36th Annual Transactions of the American Association of Cost Engineers â AACE, USA, No.R.5.1-R.5.14

Sushani, A. (2005) No joy for the small builders, The Star online, 8 May 2005, Retrieved from

The Dominion Post (2008, 29 June) Not a cent for builder's creditors: Big claims, few assets, Retrieved from

Uher, T. E., and Brand, M. C. (2005) 'Analysis of adjudication determinations made under security of payment legislation in New South Wales', International Journal of Project Management, 23 (6), 474-482,

Watts, V. M. and Scrivener, J. C. (1993) 'Review of Australian Building disputes settled by litigation', Building Research Information, 21 (1), 59-63,