Building on Shaky Ground: Quality and Safety in China’s Construction Industry in the Wake of the Wenchuan and Yushu Earthquakes

Michael Ting

Abstract


[In China, development of building regulations has largely been motivated by a desire to maintain the booming construction industry which has sustained strong economic growth. As a result, the government has fallen behind on ensuring quality and safety in residential housing projects. The devastation left by the Wenchuan and Yushu earthquakes was a grim reminder of this. This essay aims to draw out some of the regulatory mistakes that have been made and proposes solutions to the issues raised. Regulators must refocus their attention on protecting the public and lay the legislative groundwork for healthy development in the sector.]


Keywords


Wenchuan Earthquake; Quality and Safety; Construction Law in China

Full Text:

PDF

References


Australian Broadcasting Company (2008) 'Spotlight on China's Building Codes' Asia Pacific Focus, 25 May 2008

AS 1170, Standards Australia

Biz China (2010) The Tenth Five-Year Plan of the Construction Industry, Newspaper, China Daily, 28 May 2010,

Builders will be Jointly and Severally liable for the Collapse of the Construction Unit (2009) Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China (MOHURD), News release, 25 December 2009

Building Code of Australia (2009) Australian Building Codes Board

Chen, Z. G. (2002) 'A Comparison between the Construction Law of China and the Building Control Act of Singapore', Construction Law Journal, 18(4), 275â90

China National Accreditation Service for Conformity Assessment Website

China's Statistics on Urbanisation (2004) ã中å½ç»è®¡æè¦ã Bureau of Urban and Rural Population 2004

Chinese Government's Official Web Portal Website

Chinese Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development Website

Ching, F. and Winkel, S. (2009) Building Codes Illustrated: A Guide to Understanding the 2009 International Building Code, 3rd edition, International Code Council

Code for Design of Buildings for Elderly Persons (1999) ãè年人建ç­è®¾è®¡è§èã (JGJ122-99) (People's Republic of China) Ministry of Construction

Code for Architectural Design of Cinema (2008) (JGJ58-2008) (People's Republic of China).

Code for Design of Detention Houses (2007) ãæçæ建设æ åã (JGJ127-2000) (People's Republic of China) Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China (MOHURD), 27 February 2007

Code for Design of Funeral Parlor Buildings (2000) (JGJ124-99) (People's Republic of China).

Code for Design of Residential Building for the Aged (1999) ãè年人å±ä½å»ºç­è®¾è®¡æ åã (GB/T50340-2003) (People's Republic of China) Ministry of Construction

Construction Law of the People's Republic of China (1997) ã中å人æ°å±åå½å»ºç­æ³ã (People's Republic of China) National People's Congress, Order No 91, 1 November 1997('Construction Law')

Construction Supervision (2008) ã建设工ç¨ççã (Statistical Bulletin for 2007, Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China, 24 June 2008)

Declaration of 2008 on the Development of Engineering Construction Standards, Amendments to the Notification Plan (2007) ãå³äºç³æ¥2008年度工ç¨å»ºè®¾æ åå¶è®¢ã修订项ç®è®¡åçéç¥ã (People's Republic of China) The People's Republic of China Ministry of Construction Office, 19 November 2007

Design Code for Residential Buildings (2003) ãä½å®è®¾è®¡è§èã (GB50096-1999) (People's Republic of China) Ministry of Construction, 24 April 2003

Design Code for Sports Building 2003 (JGJ31-2003) (People's Republic of China)

Guo, Y. (2009) 'Quality in the National Standardization for Safety in Construction', Speech delivered onsite at Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China, 4 December 2009

Hageman, R. (1983) 'An Assessment of the Value of Natural Disasters Damage Reduction in Dwellings Due to Building Codes: Two Case Studies', Natural Resources Journal, 23, 531â48

Hoenig, J. (2009) 'Projects in China Need Vigilance' Engineering News Record, 263(19), 2

International Disaster and Risk Conferences Website

Law of the People's Republic of China on the Earthquake Prevention and Disaster Relief (2008), (People's Republic of China) National People's Congress, Order No 7, 27 December

Lee, D.2008 Lee, D. (2008) 'Building Codes Not Set in Stone', Los Angeles Times (online), 14 May 2008 < http://articles.latimes.com/2008/may/14/world/fg-construct14>

Li et al. (2003) 'China Statistical Yearbook 2003' (Statistical Yearbook No 22, National Bureau of Statistics of China, 2003) 527

Merritt, F. and Ricketts, J. (eds) (2000) Building Design and Construction Handbook, 6th edition, McGraw-Hill

Miyamoto, H. K. (2008) 'Sichuan Earthquake Disaster Chronicle: Through the Eyes of theFirst Foreign Engineers Onsite' http://www.miyamotointernational.com/pdf_files/2008%20Sichuan%20Earthquake%20Disaster%20Chronicle.pdf

Museum of Science and Technology Building Standards (2007) ãç§å­¦ææ¯é¦å»ºè®¾æ åã (People's Republic of China) The People's Republic of China Ministry ofConstruction, 27 August 2007

National Project Construction Standardization Information Network Website

National Work Conference for Construction Standards (2007) ã中å人æ°å±åå½ä½æ¿åå乡建设é¨ã (People's Republic of China) Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China (MOHURD), 3 December 2007

National Work Conference for Fixed Construction Standards (2007) ãå¨å½å·¥ç¨å»ºè®¾æ åå®é¢å·¥ä½ä¼ã Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China (MOHURD), News Release, 3 December 2007

Nelson, A. (2010) 'US Engineers Study Chile Earthquake to Bolster California Building Codes' The Christian Science Monitor (online), 2 April 2010

News Release on Building Seismic Evaluation Standards and Technical Specification for Seismic Reinforcement (2009) ãå³äºæ¹ååå¸ãå¬å®æ´¾åºæ建设æ åãçéç¥ã(People's Republic of China) The People's Republic of China Ministry of Housing and Urban Engineering Quality Safety Supervision Division, 1 July 2009

Notice for the Declaration of the Year 2008 as the Year for Development of Engineering Construction Standards (2007) ãå³äºç³æ¥2008年度工ç¨å»ºè®¾æ åå¶è®¢ã修订项ç®è®¡åçéç¥ã The People's Republic of China Ministry of Construction Office, 19 Nov 2007

Notice of the 2009 National Construction Standards, Quality, Supervision, Law Enforcement and Inspection Briefing (2009) ãå³äº2009å¹´å¨å½å»ºè®¾å·¥ç¨è´¨éçç£æ§æ³æ£æ¥æåµçéæ¥ã Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China (MOHURD), 29 December 2009

Notice on Launching the Work of Supervision of Construction (1988) ãå³äºå¼å±å»ºè®¾ççå·¥ä½çéç¥ã The People's Republic of China Ministry of Construction Office, 25 July 1988

Notification on Immediate Safety Inspection of Construction Works (2010) ãå³äºç«å³å¼å±å»ºç­æ½å·¥å®å¨ç产大æ£æ¥çéç¥ã Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China (MOHURD), 6 April 2010

Notification on Quality Residential Projects (2007) ãå³äºå好ä½å®å·¥ç¨è´¨éåæ·éªæ¶å·¥ä½çéç¥ã The People's Republic of China Ministry of Construction, 27 August 2007

Notification of the Requirements for Acceptance of Good Quality Residential Household Projects (2009) ãå³äºå好ä½å®å·¥ç¨è´¨éåæ·éªæ¶å·¥ä½çéç¥ã Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China, Order No. 291, 22 December 2009

Opinions on Launching Special Rectification Work to Address the Major Problems in the Engineering and Construction Sector (2009) (People's Republic of China) General Office of State Council, Order No. 27, 9 July 2009

Paterson, Emily, Del Re, Domenico & Wang, Zifa, (2008) The 2008 Wenchuan Earthquake: Risk Management Lessons and Implications, Discussion Paper, Risk Management Services

Police Station Construction Standards (2007) ãå¬å®æ´¾åºæ建设æ åã (JGJ127-2000) (People's Republic of China) Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China (MOHURD), 27 June 2007

Provisions on the Administration of the Qualification of Enterprises for Survey and Design of Construction Projects (2001) ã建设工ç¨åå¯è®¾è®¡ä¼ä¸èµè´¨ç®¡çè§å®ãMinistry of Construction, 25 July 2001

Regulations of the People's Republic of China on Certification and Accreditation (2003) (People's Republic of China) State Council, Order No 390, 20 August 2003

Regulations on Administration of Survey and Design of Construction Projects (2005) (People's Republic of China) State Council, Order No 293, 25 September 2005

Regulations on the Quality of Construction Projects (2000) (People's Republic of China) State Council, 30 January 2000

Reuben, Richard, (1994) 'Picking up the Pieces: Natural Disasters Shatter Insurance Rules', American Bar Association Journal, 80, 79

Rules for Preparation of Construction Standards (1999) ãå·¥ç¨å»ºè®¾æ åç¼åè§å®ã (People's Republic of China) Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China (MOHURD)

Seismic Design of Buildings (2008) ã建ç­æé设计è§èã (GB50011-2008).

Shi, P.J. (2008) 'China Wenchuan Earthquake Disaster (May 12 2008) and its Loss Assessment', International Disaster and Risk Conference, 29 August 2008, Davos Switzerland, 1-73.

Standardisation Law of The People's Republic of China (1988) ã中å人æ°å±åå½æ ååæ³ã (People's Republic of China) National People's Congress, 29 December 1988

Technical Specification for Seismic Strengthening of Buildings (2009) ã中å人æ°å±åå½è¡ä¸æ åï¼å»ºç­æéå åºææ¯è§ç¨ã Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of the People's Republic of China (MOHURD), 16 June 2009

United States Geological Survey (2010), Magnitude 6.9 -SOUTHERN QINGHAI, CHINA (14 April 2010) United States Geological Survey

Wang Y. (2004) 'Comparison of Seismic Actions and Structural Design Requirements in Chinese Code GB 50011 and International Standard ISO 3010', Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibrations, 3, 1

Weller, Richard, (2005) 'AS 1170.4 Earthquake Actions in Australia: Worked Examples', Conference on Earthquake Engineering in Australia, The Australian Earthquake Engineering Society, 2005, Albury.

Wenchuan Earthquake Restoration and Reconstruction Ordinance (2008) ã汶å·å°éç¾åæ¢å¤é建æ¡ä¾ã (People's Republic of China) State Council, Order No 526, 4 June 2008

Wu Y. and Wang S. (2009) 'Enlightenments of 512 Wenchuan Earthquake', Wenchuan Earthquake, the Path Forward, International Disaster and Risk Conference, 13â15 July 2009, Chengdu

Yushu (2010) Xinhuanet

Zhen, G. R. (2009) 'Developers of Buildings which Collapse Causing Injury and Death will be Jointly and Severally Liable', Newspaper, Xinhua, 22 December 2009

Zhu, l. (2006) 'China's Real Estate Investment Passes 5 Trillion Yuan mark', Newspaper, Xinhua (online), 30 January 2006 < http://english.gov.cn/2006-01/30/content_175605.htm>

Zuo, J. and Zillante, G. (2007) 'Building Surveying in China â Lessons learned from Australia', Australian Institute of Building Surveyors Conference, November 2007, Adelaide Australia, 351â66




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5130/AJCEB.v10i3.1712